Semi‐quantitative characterisation of mixed pollen samples using MinION sequencing and Reverse Metagenomics (RevMet)

Abstract

1. The ability to identify and quantify the constituent plant species that make up a mixed-species sample of pollen has important applications in ecology, conservation, and agriculture. Recently, metabarcoding protocols have been developed for pollen that can identify constituent plant species, but there are strong reasons to doubt that metabarcoding can accurately quantify their relative abundances. A PCR-free, shotgun metagenomics approach has greater potential for accurately quantifying species relative abundances, but applying metagenomics to eukaryotes is challenging due to low numbers of reference genomes.2. We have developed a pipeline, RevMet (Reverse Metagenomics) that allows reliable and semi-quantitative characterization of the species composition of mixed-species eukaryote samples, such as bee-collected pollen, without requiring reference genomes. Instead, reference species are represented only by 'genome skims': low-cost, low-coverage, short-read sequence datasets. The skims are mapped to individual long reads sequenced from mixed-species samples using the MinION, a portable nanopore sequencing device, and each long read is uniquely assigned to a plant species.3. We genome-skimmed 49 wild UK plant species, validated our pipeline with mock DNA mixtures of known composition, and then applied RevMet to pollen loads collected from wild bees. We demonstrate that RevMet can identify plant species present in mixed-species samples at proportions of DNA ≥ 1%, with few false positives and false negatives, and reliably differentiate species represented by high versus low amounts of DNA in a sample.4. RevMet could readily be adapted to generate semi-quantitative datasets for a wide range of mixed eukaryote samples. Our per-sample costs were £90 per genome skim and £60 per pollen sample, and new versions of sequencers available now will further reduce these costs. K E Y W O R D Sbees, diet analysis, genome skim, metabarcoding, metagenomics, MinION, pollen, quantitative | 1691Methods in Ecology and Evoluঞon PEEL Et aL.

Using RNA-seq to characterize pollen–stigma interactions for pollination studies

“…This allowed us to distinguish cultivar outcross pollination events from self-pollination or no pollination, which has not yet been possible with traditional barcoding markers. Since the first application of DNA barcoding to pollen, the field of pollination ecology has now expanded its methodological toolbox of DNA sequencing for taxonomic identification and many other palynology applications 13,16 , including a greater understanding of pollinator diet preferences 14,15,17,[47][48][49] . Within crop systems, however, a different molecular approach is required if a taxonomic resolution is needed at the cultivar level.…”

Biodiversity Soup II: A bulk-sample metabarcoding pipeline emphasizing error reduction

“…Fortunately, methods for estimating within-sample species frequencies are being developed in metagenomic pipelines (Lang et al . 2019; Peel et al . 2019).…”

Genetic Biomonitoring and Biodiversity Assessment Using Portable Sequencing Technologies: Current Uses and Future Directions

“…The long-read length of nanopore sequencing also offers great opportunities for pooled sample or bulk community metagenomics [50,61]. A major drawback of this technique is the current lack of whole-genome reference data for many species [54].…”

“…Consequently, the vast majority of metagenomic reads cannot be assigned to taxon level and have to be excluded from the analysis. Recent work suggests a solution to this problem by “reverse metagenomics” [61]. Here, a whole-genome reference database of low coverage Illumina short reads is generated for target taxa in the community.…”