Semantic Network Analysis Using Construction Accident Cases to Understand Workers’ Unsafe Acts

Abstract

Unsafe acts by workers are a direct cause of accidents in the labor-intensive construction industry. Previous studies have reviewed past accidents and analyzed their causes to understand the nature of the human error involved. However, these studies focused their investigations on only a small number of construction accidents, even though a large number of them have been collected from various countries. Consequently, this study developed a semantic network analysis (SNA) model that uses approximately 60,000 construction accident cases to understand the nature of the human error that affects safety in the construction industry. A modified human factor analysis and classification system (HFACS) framework was used to classify major human error factors—that is, the causes of the accidents in each of the accident summaries in the accident case data—and an SNA analysis was conducted on all of the classified data to analyze correlations between the major factors that lead to unsafe acts. The results show that an overwhelming number of accidents occurred due to unintended acts such as perceptual errors (PERs) and skill-based errors (SBEs). Moreover, this study visualized the relationships between factors that affected unsafe acts based on actual construction accident case data, allowing for an intuitive understanding of the major keywords for each of the factors that lead to accidents.

The modeling factors work shifts, fatigue and unsafe actions on work accidents at PT PLN Barru, Indonesia

“…According to the International Labor Organization, nearly 120 million work accidents occur each year, 210 thousand resulting in fatal injuries due to unsafe acts at work (Niza et al, 2008). Some of the factors that influence unsafe actions that can cause work accidents are workers who have excessive workloads, undirected work shifts, lack of supervision while working, physically unstable workers, work stress (time pressure) and insufficient rest (Kang et al, 2021). The results of research conducted on technical workers of PT.…”

A multi-level safety culture maturity model for (new) building projects in Hong Kong

“…Reason's work represented the cognitive psychological school of thought associated with accidents and human error, whereby systems fail due to a human error from a slip, a lapse, a mistake or a violation (Reason, 2000). The human error approach has a strong body of knowledge such as the semantic network analysis of 60,000 Korean case studies illustrating that accidents' highest contributions were from human error and skill-based error (Kang et al, 2021).…”

A Cognitive Systems Engineering Approach Using Unsupervised Fuzzy C-Means Technique, Exploratory Factor Analysis and Network Analysis—A Preliminary Statistical Investigation of the Bean Counter Profiling Scale Robustness

“…To en-399 sure the correctness of our network analysis, the network needs to be a sufficiently accu-400 rate representation of the underlying data in order to guarantee the scientific accuracy 401 [61]. Since the aim of this study is to bring as much as possible statistical evidence for the six-factorial structure of the Bean Counter Profiling Scale, we have employed network 403 analysis for adding empirical rigor [62][63][64][65] besides results obtained with factorial and 404 Additional fit indices yielded an RMSEA of 0.052 and a TLI of 0.816 for the entire 68-item BCPS, indicating an acceptable general model fit.…”