Self-perception of leadership styles and behaviour in primary health care

Abstract

BackgroundThe concept of leadership has been studied in various disciplines and from different theoretical approaches. It is a dynamic concept that evolves over time. There are few studies in our field on managers’ self-perception of their leadership style. There are no pure styles, but one or another style is generally favoured to a greater or lesser degree. In the primary health care (PHC) setting, managers’ leadership style is defined as a set of attitudes, behaviours, beliefs and values. The objectives of this study were to describe and learn about the self-perception of behaviours and leadership styles among PHC managers; to determine the influence of the leadership style on job satisfaction, efficiency, and willingness to work in a team; and to determine the relationship between transformational and transactional styles according age, gender, profession, type of manager years of management experience, and the type of organization.MethodsTo describe leadership styles as perceived by PHC managers, a cross sectional study was performed using an 82 items-self-administered Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire (MLQ). This questionnaire measures leadership styles, attitudes and behaviour of managers. The items are grouped into three first order variables (transformational, transactional and laissez-faire) and ten second order variables (which discriminate leader behaviours). Additionally, the questionnaire evaluates organizational consequences such as extra-effort, efficiency and satisfaction.ResultsOne hundred forty responses from 258 managers of 133 PHC teams in the Barcelona Health Area (response rate: 54.26 %). Most participants were nurses (61.4 %), average age was 49 years and the gender predominantly female (75 %). Globally, managers assessed themselves as equally transactional and transformational leaders (average: 3.30 points).Grouped by profession, nurses (28.57 % of participants) showed a higher transactional leadership style, over transformational leadership style, compared to physicians (3.38 points, p < 0.003). Considering gender, men obtained the lowest results in transactional style (p < 0.015). Both transactional and transformational styles correlate with efficiency and job satisfaction (r = 0.724 and r = 0.710, respectively).ConclusionsPHC managers’ self-perception of their leadership style was transactional, focused on the maintenance of the status quo, although there was a trend in some scores towards the transformational style, mainly among nurse managers. Both styles correlate with satisfaction and willingness to strive to work better.

Nursing leadership styles and their impact on intensive care unit quality measures: An integrative review

“…TL is characterized by individual consideration, intellectual stimulation, inspirational motivation and idealized influence (Doody & Doody, 2012). Transactional leadership is another common leadership style (Solà, Badia, Hito, Osaba, & Del Val García, 2016); it is characterized by management by exception and contingent rewards. Other leadership styles include Laissez-faire leadership, authentic leadership, resonant leadership (Laschinger, Wong, Cummings, & Grau, 2014), relational, situational or task-oriented leadership, and situational leadership (McCay, Lyles, & Larkey, 2018).…”

Leadership and the functioning of maternal health services in two rural district hospitals in South Africa

“…Alloubani et al (2014) in a review of effects of leadership styles on quality of services in health care found that transformational leadership characteristics have positive effects on organizational outcomes, including: ‘teamwork success, effectiveness, staff satisfaction, commitment and extra effort and others’. Other studies have also shown that strengthening leadership can increase the chances of improving performance ( Lembani et al 2015 ; Sola et al 2016 ). Al-Sawai (2013) further emphasized the need for effective leadership to focus on the dynamic relationships between leadership values, culture, capabilities and the organizational context anchored by a high level of self, team and organizational awareness.…”

“…These aspects of leadership style, such as use of data to improve service delivery, supportive leadership, teamwork have been reported in other studies ( Puoane et al 2008 ; Curry et al 2012 ; Lembani et al 2015 ). Sola et al (2016) study on self-perception of leadership styles and behaviour in primary health care classified this leadership style as ‘transformational’ and explained that it encourages teamwork, collaboration, empathy and the acceptance and use of innovativeness which results in improvement of outcomes as compared to the more rigid and bureaucratic leadership styles. Similar observations were made by other studies on transformational leadership ( Schaubroeck et al 2007 ; Top et al 2013 ).…”

Liderança coaching na enfermagem e sua influência na satisfação profissional e segurança do paciente

“…Nesse contexto, pesquisadores têm demonstrado relação entre modelos de liderança contemporâneos e melhores resultados referentes à segurança do paciente e à satisfação dos profissionais, fatores esses que podem contribuir para a melhoria da qualidade da assistência (6)(7) . Dentre esses modelos de liderança, têm sido apontadas na literatura a Liderança transacional (8) , Liderança transformacional (9) , Liderança autêntica (10) , e a Liderança coaching, sendo essa última pautada por um processo de promoção e estímulo da aprendizagem, com orientação prática em busca do alcance de metas relacionadas ao desenvolvimento técnico e pessoal (11)(12) .…”