Quantum well states in thin metal films are strongly influenced by the electronic and geometric structure of the underlying substrate. This impedes a comparison to ab initio calculations generally based on free-standing films. Here we show that Pb films deposited on single-crystalline, epitaxial graphite are an excellent approximation to free-standing metal films. We find Pb islands of four monolayer height to be most stable, followed by other even-numbered islands, in excellent agreement with theoretical predictions for the formation of preferred island heights. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.75.161401 PACS number͑s͒: 79.60.Dp, 73.21.Fg, 68.55.Jk, 71.15.Ϫm The electronic structure and morphology of ultrathin metal films is a subject of intense scientific and technological interest. In such films, the thicknesses are comparable to the electron coherence length, and quantum well states ͑QWSs͒ may form due to electron confinement in the direction normal to the surface. 1,2 Many physical properties therefore show a strong dependence on layer thickness, and such quantum size effects ͑QSEs͒ have been found to induce, and thus to be reflected in, the oscillation with the thickness of macroscopic properties such as sign and magnitude of the Hall effect, 3,4 reactivity and absorption, 5 the magnitude of the superconducting transition temperature, 6,7 and details of the growth morphology. 8 Moreover, the study of electron confinement in metal films has contributed to an understanding of basic solid-state physics phenomena such as electronphonon coupling. 9 One of the striking consequences of electron confinement is its influence on film growth morphology. Zhang and co-workers have predicted the formation of "critical" and "magic" island heights from a theoretical study of the variation of the total energy with coverage. Their "electronic growth" model 10 has been corroborated by a number of experiments. Such growth morphologies were found to depend sensitively on details of the interface structure. 11 Scanning tunnelling microscopy ͑STM͒ results from the Pb/ Cu͑111͒ system 12 show a variety of preferred island heights, partly depending on the step density of the substrate. Direct proof of the interplay between electronic structure and morphology is derived from the observation of quantum well states in angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy ͑ARPES͒. Here an assignment of specific island thicknesses can be obtained through an analysis of photoemission peaks due to quantum well states on the basis of the so-called phase accumulation model. 13 Since the substrate apparently has a strong influence on the development of specific preferred thicknesses, it appears preferable to study metal film growth on a material which exhibits a very weak interaction with the overlayer. This is also advantageous because calculations of metal film behavior rely on free-standing slab models, since the interface of the ͑in general incommensurate͒ substrate/film lattices is difficult to model. Graphite is a material that is known to interact weakl...