Self-Construal and Subjective Wellbeing in Two Ethnic Communities in Singapore

Abstract

The study reported here addressed two questions concerning the applicability to other collectivist cultures of a model developed on the basis of socially defined self-construals and their consequences for subjective wellbeing (Kwan, Bond, & Singelis, 1997). In contrast to the social centrality of the Singaporean Chinese, Islam enjoys centrality in the Malay community. Is subjective well-being in these two cultures attributable to independent or interdependent self-construal? Do parallel paths to subjective wellbeing originate from these two forms of self-construal? Are the respective mediators, self-esteem and relationship harmony, functioning in the same way in these different communities? Two hundred and eighty-six participants (121 Malays, including 49 females and 72 males, and 165 Chinese, including 62 males and 103 females, average age, 18.52) were drawn from three tertiary technical training institutes in Singapore. Independent and interdependent self-construal, Rosenberg's Self-esteem Scale (SE), the Relationship Harmony Scale (RH) (Kwan, et al. 1997) and the Satisfaction with Life Scale (SL) (Diener, Emmons. Larsen, & Griffins, 1985) were administered to test the model. For the Chinese, the best-fit model required a path between the two forms of self-construal, confirming their overlapping nature. For the Malays, a radically different model fits the data: relationship harmony no longer functions as a mediator but as an independent contributor in its own right. These results raise questions about the meaning and consequences of socially defined self-construal in different collectivist cultures, and the path between the self and subjective wellbeing.

Not All Forms of Independence Are Created Equal: Only Being Independent the “Right Way” Is Associated With Self-Esteem and Life Satisfaction

“…Study 1 results replicated previous findings ( Kwan et al, 1997 ; Chang et al, 2011 ; Duan et al, 2013 ; Yu et al, 2016 ), showing that unidimensional independence and life satisfaction are positively and indirectly related, by self-esteem mediating the relationship. A potential explanation of this mediation mechanism is provided by Markus and Kitayama (1991) , who argued that individuals’ own evaluation of their self-worth, which is strongly connected with their life satisfaction, is dependent on the cultural standards encompassed in their self-construal.…”

Measures of Children’s Subjective Well-Being: Analysis of the Potential for Cross-National Comparisons

“…A number of studies have identified differences between East Asian and European-American respondents. East Asian repondents have been found to have a tendency to give less extreme answers than European-Americans (Boehm et al 2011;Chong et al 2011;Hommerich and Klient 2012;Tov and Diener 2007).…”

Understanding Word-of-Mouth in Counterfeiting

“…Not surprisingly, consumers' likelihood of buying a counterfeit brand is inversely related to the price of the genuine brand. The third and fourth categories refer to the social and cultural context in which the counterfeit purchase decision is made, ranging from cultural norms (Chang et al, 2011;Lai & Zaichkowsky, 1999) to the shopping environment (Leisen & Nill, 2001). For example, consumers are likely to purchase a counterfeit brand when they react more favorably to the shopping environment.…”