The low abundance and activity of catalytic antibodies are major obstacles to their selection from the virtually unlimited repertoire of antibody binding sites. The requirement for new screening methodologies is further emphasized by the availability ofcombinatorial libraries, in which a functional polypeptide has to be selected out of millions of possibilities. We present a simple and sensitive screening approach (termed catELISA) based on immobilized substrates and immunodetection of the end product of the catalyzed reaction. (4), which are then screened to select those clones producing monoclonal antibodies that bind the hapten. The direct screening of culture supernatants of these hybridomas for antibody catalysis was heretofore not possible due to relatively high background reaction, the generally low catalytic efficiency of antibodies, and contaminating enzymes that catalyze the same reaction (5). Therefore, to detect catalytic activity, large quantities (usually from ascites fluid) of purified monoclonal antibodies are needed. Only a few, and occasionally none, of the dozens of clones that bind a hapten are catalytic; it is therefore widely recognized that these inefficient and labor-intensive procedures must be replaced by rapid and direct screening procedures (2,3,(6)(7)(8)27). Novel, nonhybridoma, methodologies, such as combinatorial variable-region cloning in phage (9, 10), were also used to generate antibodies. Yet, as noted (11), future applications of these methodologies for obtaining catalytic antibodies depend upon appropriate screening. Analysis of the unique problems involved in direct screening of hybridoma supernatants for antibody-mediated catalysis (5) led us to catELISA, an assay involving a substrateprotein conjugate immobilized on microtiter plates. Antibody-catalyzed conversion of any "solid-phase" substrate to a product is then detected by ordinary ELISA, using binding anti-product antibodies (Fig. 1) were able to rapidly screen thousands of hybridoma clones elicited against both a phosphonate TS analog and an amide substrate to detect catalytic cleavage of the corresponding p-nitrobenzyl ester.
MATERIALS AND METHODSPreparation of Substrates and Hapten. All of the synthesized substances were purified to homogeneity (udged by thin-layer chromatography and NMR) by crystallization or silica column chromatography. Structures were confirmed by NMR and mass spectrum; satisfactory elemental analyses were obtained for all crystalline compounds. Esters la, lb, and le and amide 2 (Fig. 2) were prepared by the following procedures: (i) allowing the corresponding alcohol or amine to react with glutaric anhydride in the presence of a base (lb, ethanol, sodium ethoxide, reflux; la and le, p-nitrobenzyl alcohol or o-nitrobenzyl alcohol, 1,8-diazabicyclo[5.4.0]-undecane (DBU); 2, p-nitrobenzylamine; Et3N); (ii) coupling of t-butyl glycinate by using the acid chloride prepared with thionyl chloride; and (iii) removal of the t-butyl ester in the presence of trifluoroacetic acid. The methyl est...