Seldom heard voices: a meta-narrative systematic review of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples healthcare experiences

Abstract

Background It is well established that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander populations face considerable health inequities, exacerbated by poorer healthcare quality. Patient experience is recognised as a major contributing factor to healthcare quality and outcomes, therefore, enriched knowledge of the patient experiences of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander populations is critical to redress health inequities. This review synthesises evidence of the healthcare experiences amongst Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patients through a metanarrative synthesis of qualitative literature. Methods A systematic search strategy was developed and applied to six electronic databases between January 2000 and July 2019. Titles and abstracts were screened before applying the inclusion criteria to full text articles. A meta-narrative synthesis was undertaken. Results Fifty-four publications were identified from four research traditions; each with a unique conceptualisation of patient experience. Three themes emerged that demonstrate Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patient experiences are informed by 1) beliefs about wellbeing and healthcare provision, 2) their level of trust in the healthcare system, and 3) individual and community health system interactions. The findings highlight a range of aspects of patient experience that were important to participating Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders in the included studies but not captured currently in health system surveys. Conclusion This review highlights the influence of beliefs about health and wellbeing on the patient experience amongst Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander populations in the Australian health system. Patient experiences were informed by past experience and their trust in the health system. The different factors influencing patient experience and the gravity of their influence must be considered in current approaches to capturing patient experience data collection methods. Trial registration PROSPERO (ID: CRD42019134765).

A strengths-based approach to exploring diabetes management in an Indigenous minority population: A mixed methods study

“…Critical interactionist analytical approaches also use narratives to facilitate shifting the discourse away from the dominant academic/social voice and centering the perspectives of marginalized groups, so that 'their lived experience becomes the vehicle through which new knowledge is not only created but also made relevant to the communities of concern' [37:499]. Narrative-and storytelling-methods are increasingly being used in public health research [40][41][42][43][44] because they enable healthcare providers and policy makers to virtually experience, and thus better understand and address, the multi-level effects of social determinants on their patients' lives, health, and healthcare experiences [13,14,[42][43][44][45]. The results of the quantitative multivariable analyses also supported the connections described by focus group participants between socioeconomic, psychological, health, and healthcare system factors and the healthcare access, economic barrier, health behavior and mental health outcomes we examined.…”

Mitigating unintended consequences of co‐design in health care

“…Undertaking a co‐design approach without the optimal conditions for inclusive involvement by all may not result in an equal partnership or improve health or care quality outcomes. 37 , 38 , 39 There is a risk of further marginalizing or adding burden to populations under‐represented and over‐researched with very little evidence that their involvement has improved the health system for them. 6 , 13 , 26 Co‐design in health services is messy and complex, involving diverse actors with various abilities and statuses.…”

“You Can’t Work with My People If You Don’t Know How to”: Enhancing Transfer of Care from Hospital to Primary Care for Aboriginal Australians with Chronic Disease

“…Around the world, different and shared experiences of racism, including systemic racism, continue to adversely impact the health of Indigenous peoples [ 38 , 39 , 40 ]. Long-term structural inequities continue to play out at the point of care, where negative experiences inform Aboriginal people’s level of trust of the health systems [ 41 ]. Cultural security has been described as a key element of effective services for Indigenous peoples globally and “an ongoing journey” [ 42 ].…”