Gresens SE, Stur E, Ekrem T. 2012. Phenotypic and genetic variation within the Cricotopus sylvestris species-group (Diptera, Chironomidae), across a Nearctic -Palaearctic gradient. Fauna norvegica 31: 137-149.Intraspecific variation sometimes obscures species boundaries and makes identification of certain Chironomidae difficult. This is true for many species in the genus Cricotopus. We used DNA barcode data and multivariate statistical analyses to investigate which phenotypic characters in populations of the Cricotopus sylvestris species-group are useful for species identification. Specimens collected across a broad latitudinal range from the Southwest United States through subarctic Canada to northern Norway formed nine distinct barcode clusters. Body size of adult flies decreased by 51% from the northern to southernmost populations. Meristic characters in wings and legs were strongly related to overall body size, and related morphometric ratios were not species specific. Antennal ratio increased significantly with body size, thus limiting its value in species delimitation. Non-metric ordinations of setal and coloration pattern data were characteristic for most species in the sylvestris-group. DNA barcode data worked well in separating morphologically different populations, except for the case of C. (I.) sylvestris and C. (I.) trifasciatus, which were distinguished by ordination of color pattern, but not by barcoding data. These two species appeared closely related, and we conclude that sequence data from neutral nuclear markers will be necessary to determine if these are genetically distinct species, or whether there is merely a high level of environmental plasticity in pigmentation within this geographically widespread barcode cluster. doi: 10.5324/fn.v31i0.1417. Received: 2011-11-29. Accepted: 2012. Published on paper and online: 2012-10-17.Keywords: DNA barcoding, morphometrics, phenotypic plasticity, species delimitation, color pattern Sciences, Towson University, 8000 York, Towson, MD 21252-0001, USA 2. Museum of Natural History and Archaeology, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NO-7491, Trondheim, Norway Corresponding author: Susan E. Gresens E-mail: sgresens@towson.edu Hirabayashi et al. 2004). Species-level identification of adult Cricotopus is difficult because high levels of intraspecific variation lead to overlap in the values of morphological traits between species. This is particularly true for many mensural data; coloration and the pattern of setae on thorax and the abdominal tergites are therefore important for identification of Cricotopus species (Hirvenoja 1973). Within a species, however, pigmentation varies seasonally and geographically (LeSage & Harrison 1980; Boesel 1983;Oliver & Dillon 1988) and can potentially obscure otherwise good differences
Department of Biological
INTrOduCTIONThe genus Cricotopus van der Wulp, 1874 is one of the largest in the Orthocladiinae, containing five subgenera, with species distributed across the globe (Cranston et al. 1989). Aquati...