Scope, content and quality of clinical pharmacy practice guidelines: a systematic review

Abstract

Background Guidelines for pharmacy practitioners regarding various clinical pharmacy activities have been published in a number of countries. There is a need to review the guidelines and identify the scope of activities covered as a prelude to developing internationally acceptable common guidelines. Aim To review the scope of clinical pharmacy guidelines and assess the extent to which these guidelines conform to quality standards as per the AGREE II instrument. Method Medline, Embase, Guideline Central, International Pharmaceutical Abstracts, Google Scholar and Google (for grey literature) were searched for the period 2010 to January 2023. Guidelines which focused on any health care setting and any clinical pharmacy activity were included. Data were extracted and quality assessed independently by two reviewers using the English version of the AGREE II instrument. Results Thirty-eight guidelines were included, mostly originating from Australia (n = 10), Ireland (n = 8), UK (n = 7) and USA (n = 5). Areas covered included medication reconciliation, medicines optimisation, medication management and transition of care. As per the AGREE II assessment, the highest score was obtained for the scope and purpose domain and the lowest score for rigour of development, mainly due to non-consideration of literature/evidence to inform guideline development. Conclusion Clinical pharmacy guidelines development processes need to focus on all quality domains and should take a systematic approach to guideline development. Guidelines need to further emphasise person-centred care and clinical communication. There is a scope to harmonise the guidelines internationally considering the diverse practices, standards and legislations across different geographies.

Clinical pharmacy key performance indicators for hospital inpatient setting: a systematic review

“…Clinical pharmacy, integral to the healthcare system, is defined by the American College of Clinical Pharmacy (ACCP) as the "area of pharmacy concerned with the science and practice of rational medication use"[ 2 ]. While implementation guidelines for clinical pharmacy services (CPS) strongly emphasise enhancing the rational and secure use of drugs, they do not specify indicators for assessing their quality [ 3 – 6 ].…”