Science facilitation: navigating the intersection of intellectual and interpersonal expertise in scientific collaboration

Abstract

Today’s societal challenges, such as climate change and global pandemics, are increasingly complex and require collaboration across scientific disciplines to address. Scientific teams bring together individuals of varying backgrounds and expertise to work collaboratively on creating new knowledge to address these challenges. Within a scientific team, there is inherent diversity in disciplinary cultures and preferences for interpersonal collaboration. Such diversity contributes to the potential strength of the created knowledge but can also impede progress when teams struggle to collaborate productively. Facilitation is a professional practice-based form of interpersonal expertise that supports group members to do their best thinking. Although facilitation has been demonstrated to support group functioning in a wide range of contexts, its role in supporting scientific teams has been largely overlooked. This essay defines scientific facilitation as a form of interactional expertise and explains how facilitating scientific teams requires skills in managing interpersonal interactions as well as understanding how different types of disciplinary knowledge integrate in the creation of new knowledge. Next, it explains how this science facilitation expertise may be developed through metacognition. Finally, it provides examples of how scientific facilitation could be more widely incorporated into research by describing three pathways to expand the use of facilitation theory and techniques in collaborative scientific research: developing facilitation skills among scientists leading teams, using broadly trained facilitators, and using specialised science facilitators. The strengths and risks of each path are discussed, and criteria are suggested for selecting the right approach for a given team science project.

Optimizing Collaboration Skills in the 21st Century: Recent Innovations in Project Model Differentiated Learning

“…Similar to the product design activity, the process of crafting the project work schedule also requires students' collaboration skills, particularly in the aspect of cooperation during discussions to determine the project's timetable. This trains students to appreciate the opinions/ideas of their group members, take responsibility for organizing the project work schedule through effective communication, and demonstrate self-awareness in adhering to the schedule they have developed (Aufa et al, 2021;Cravens et al, 2022). Through interactive activities during the project preparation process, collaboration skills can be enhanced (Irwan et al, 2023;Hasan, 2023).…”

“…One of the key competencies in 21 st -century education is collaboration (Castañer & Oliveira, 2020;Sholikha & Fitrayati, 2021). Collaboration involves a form of constructive social interaction in solving a problem collectively, making the success of collaboration heavily dependent on the quality of various knowledge, responsibilities, and trust that emerge within the group (Cravens et al, 2022;Kostis et al, 2022). In this context, students learn from each other's experiences and knowledge, thus enabling them to develop critical thinking, creativity, and communication skills (Conklin, 2013;Devi et al, 2023).…”

Towards effective collaborations: Reflections and recommendations for adult education and STEM

“…Team science can often be complicated by different disciplinary perspectives, expectations of what counts as knowledge or research, and who is making the decisions. Teams may actively need facilitation processes to run effectively (Cravens, Jones, et al., 2022). It's important to make an active decision about how teams will work and whether team meetings will be facilitated by an inside leader or whether someone needs to be brought in from outside the core team.…”

Fisheries Volume 49 Number 7 July 2024

“…Professionals may be brought in for high-confl ict, high-stakes, or short-term Engagement efforts. However, managers who wish to participate in these types of longterm efforts, which can also be used to measure the effectiveness of Outreach efforts, also need to cultivate these skills FISHERIES | www.fi sheries.org 325 as part of their ongoing relationships with their audiences (Cravens et al 2022 ).…”