Science as an Institution

Abstract

1. Introduction. The purpose of this paper is to present an initial sociological analysis of science as an institution. This kind of analysis has long been made of other aspects of culture: of the family, the state, religion, economic enterprise and the like. An institution, as the term is used here, is simply… a definite and established phase of the public mind … often seeming, on account of its permanence and the visible customs and symbols in which it is clothed, to have a somewhat distinct and independent existence. (6, p. 313)

Similar Attitudes, Different Strategies: A Limited Survey of the Discourse Strategies to Oppose Genetically Modified Organisms Conspiracy Theories by Chinese Scientist Communicators and Citizen Communicators on Zhihu

“…"Institution-based trust" refers to the trust generated by the guarantee of various professional materials, bureaucratic organizations and professional institutions (Jin, 2018, p. 160). When proving their attitude toward GMOs conspiracy theories, scientist science communicators suggest that it violates professional scientific knowledge or "science" as a social institution (Hartung, 1951). For instance:…”

On the limits of the political: The problem of overly permissive pluralism in Mouffe's agonism

“…Hence, science is more than a systematic aggregation of justified empirical statements. It is “a system of social rules and related objects which, existing independently of any given person, constrains his behaviour” (Hartung, 1951, p. 44). The norms of proper scientific activity, such as peer reviewing, replicability and statistical rigor, are enforced and crystallized in organizations such as universities and research institutes.…”

Engagement for progress: applied philosophy of science in context

“…Frank 1949;Merton 1949-Merton's essay is part of a symposium on "Applied Social Research in Policy Formation"), on the sociology of knowledge (e.g. Hartung 1947Hartung , 1951Hartung , 1952Hinshaw 1948), and on the production of science in a social context (Littauer 1954;Shepard 1956). It also carried on a fairly robust discussion concerning the possibility of a science of ethics (e.g.…”