Scare-Quoting and Incorporation

Abstract

I explain a mechanism I call "incorporation," that I think is at work in a wide range of cases often put under the heading of "scare-quoting." Incorporation is flagging some words in one's own utterance to indicate that they are to be interpreted as if uttered by some other speaker in some other context, while supplying evidence to one's interpreter enabling them to identify that other speaker and context. This mechanism gives us a way to use others' vocabularies and contexts, thereby extending our expressive capacities on the fly. Explaining incorporation involves explaining intra-sentential shifts in lexicon and in context. Shifts of the former sort are familiar to linguists under the heading of "code-switching." Shifts of the latter sort have been less explored; accordingly I explain how to modify Kaplan's logic of demonstratives to allow for such shifts. I compare the incorporation account of scare-quoting with accounts offered by Brandom, Recanati, Geurts and Maier, Benbaji, Predelli, and Shan. Finally I note a possible implication concerning the speech act of assertion: that you can properly assert a content you do not believe, let alone know, because part of it is expressed with words you do not understand.

Samesaying and double-voiced discourse in Iranian EFL learners’ production of L2 reported speech

“…This is exactly the reason for making a distinction between reporting as a pragmatic act (in which the polyphony of utterances can remain implicit) and marking reports in the language structure, that is, making the polyphony apparent in the ‘stable conventionalised patterns of the language itself’, in Voloshinov’s phrase. In compliance with McCullagh (2017, p. 10):One can hear some words uttered but not know what language they are in; or who is uttering them; or where the speaker is. In such a case one does not know enough about the utterance to be justified in selecting any particular lexicon (the first case) or giving any particular values to the contextual parameters.…”

Sealand, HavenCo, and the Rule of Law

“…He does not at this time have a valid visa for return." 495 Lackey went, of all places, to Iraq, where he founded an ISP, Blue Iraq, providing Internet connectivity for the military and contractors. 496 The new HavenCo also took a rather different attitude toward offshore hosting.…”