Scaling the Equipment and Play Area in Children’s Sport to improve Motor Skill Acquisition: A Systematic Review

Abstract

BackgroundThis review investigated the influence of scaling sports equipment and play area (e.g., field size) on children’s motor skill acquisition.MethodsPeer-reviewed studies published prior to February 2015 were searched using SPORTDiscus and MEDLINE. Studies were included if the research (a) was empirical, (b) involved participants younger than 18 years, (c) assessed the efficacy of scaling in relation to one or more factors affecting skill learning (psychological factors, skill performance and skill acquisition factors, biomechanical factors, cognitive processing factors), and (d) had a sport or movement skills context. Risk of bias was assessed in relation to selection bias, detection bias, attrition bias, reporting bias and other bias.ResultsTwenty-five studies involving 989 children were reviewed. Studies revealed that children preferred using scaled equipment over adult equipment (n = 3), were more engaged in the task (n = 1) and had greater self-efficacy to execute skills (n = 2). Eighteen studies demonstrated that children performed skills better when the equipment and play area were scaled. Children also acquired skills faster in such conditions (n = 2); albeit the practice interventions were relatively short. Five studies showed that scaling led to children adopting more desirable movement patterns, and one study associated scaling with implicit motor learning.ConclusionMost of the studies reviewed provide evidence in support of equipment and play area scaling. However, the conclusions are limited by the small number of studies that examined learning (n = 5), poor ecological validity and skills tests of few trials.

Interacting Learning Processes during Skill Acquisition: Learning to control with gradually changing system dynamics

“…Thus, internal forward models of new tools or objects have to be acquired during skill acquisition and have to be adjusted to changes of body dynamics during development or to external changes when the dynamics of the object change 32 . The dynamics of external objects change for instance frequently during skill acquisition when different objects or sport devices are used as part of the training, such as different tennis rackets [33][34][35] . In the beginning of the learning process devices are used which are easier to handle and thus lead earlier to successful behaviour.…”

A Constraint-Led Approach to Coaching and Teaching Games: Can going back to the future solve the «they need the basics before they can play a game» argument?

“…What should be clear for practitioners, and those interested in developing talented games players, is that more attention needs to be paid to the design of practice environments as well as the functional rules of games such as pitch or court size, ball dimensions, racket sizes and so on. While some sports have begun to address such issues and some research is emerging that looks at scaling in junior sport (see Buszard, Reid, Masters, & Farrow, 2016, to see how little research is out there), there is still much to be done. The relational properties created by games rules and young games players have been captured in research using GCAs.…”

Learning, activity… and injury? Caring for young athletes through appropriately designed modified (developmental) sport

“…Our systematic review highlighted that there was limited scientific evidence on the effects of modified sport; both from the perspective of learning but even more so injury and health 5. We had to dig back to 2005 to find a study that specifically explored the issue 6.…”