Safety of transportation buildings against vehicle bomb attacks with multi-criteria decision-making

Abstract

PurposeThis study aims to focus on security measures for protecting transportation buildings from vehicle bomb attacks. It discusses ways to mitigate the effects of vehicle bomb terrorist attacks through architectural design decisions on transportation buildings.Design/methodology/approachThe main research topic is the evaluation of architectural design decisions for vehicle bomb attacks at transportation buildings with the multi-criteria decision-making method. First, it was investigated which characteristics the impact of the explosion on the structures depended on. The measures for vehicle bomb attacks regarding the relationship between the urban scale and the building were determined by four main criteria and 17 sub-criteria. Due to the complex and ambiguous nature of architectural design, these criteria were evaluated by the analytic hierarchy processes. After the criteria weights were obtained, the alternative sample buildings, including the train stations and airports, were evaluated with the Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to an Ideal Solution method.FindingsThe site security design was determined as the most effective component for vehicle bomb attacks among the main criteria. The most important sub-criterion was the perimeter firewall. In the evaluations of the alternatives, it was determined that airports performed better against vehicle bomb attacks in terms of architectural design requirements than train stations.Originality/valueThis research contributes to the literature for the countries where explosions occur intensively by determining the importance of architectural design parameters for the transportation buildings and surroundings against vehicle bomb attacks. This study provides an evaluation model based on transportation buildings considering the relationship between the urban scale and the building itself.

Analysis of earthquake resilience factors for buildings: the case of Istanbul high-rise buildings

“…A well-planned transportation network, including intercity, primary and secondary roads, is crucial for evacuation and aid efforts after a disaster. These roads should remain accessible and not blocked, provide access to safe gathering and sheltering areas, allow for debris removal and facilitate the delivery of necessary supplies to disaster victims (İlerisoy and Gökgöz, 2023).…”

City identity and singularity: people's preferences about development projects in Cairo

“…During the analysis stage, the initial step entails structuring the gathered attributes from the literature review. These characteristics have been grouped using MCDM approach (İlerisoy and Gökgöz, 2022; Huang and Perng, 2018). This approach was used here to help decision-makers evaluate and prioritise different alternatives when faced with multiple and often conflicting criteria.…”

Importance performance analysis for sustainability of reused historical building: Mardin Sabanci City Museum and art gallery

“…In the first stage, based on the data obtained from the literature, the parameters affecting the sustainability of reused historical buildings were determined. Within the scope of the study, the sustainability of reused historical buildings is discussed under 4 headings: functional, technical, aesthetic and environmental sustainability (Preiser, 1988; Van der Voordt and Van Wegen, 2005; Canbay Türkyılmaz and Polatoğlu, 2012; Yaldız and Asatekin, 2016; Fakıbaba Dedeoğlu, 2019; İlerisoy and Gökgöz, 2023). Sub-parameters for each parameter were then created based on the literature.…”