Safety Impact Prediction of Redesigning National Roads Crossing Residential Areas: An Italian Case Study

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to determine the safety effectiveness of an intervention on an existing road by using predictive methods. Predictive methods allow the benefit of the intervention to be quantified in terms of crash reduction. Currently, the most widely used model is reported in the Highway Safety Manual, developed in the US. The HSM model is adapted to the Italian context through a calibration procedure. The model is then applied to two future scenarios: in the absence and presence of intervention. The redesign intervention consists of rehabilitating some road sections and constructing five tunnel bypasses to avoid crossing residential areas. The comparison between the ‘with’ and ‘without’ scenario estimated an overall reduction in the number of accidents of around 45%. The variant scenario is based on reasonable assumptions that allowed the determination of the proportion of traffic that will be diverted to the variant. In addition, several alternative future scenarios are considered to assess a possible different trend in assumed traffic distribution. Moreover, a possible overall increase or reduction in total traffic affecting the road is taken into account. The results showed that the intervention provided significant benefits even with increased traffic, proving the resilience of the intervention.