Russians in post-Soviet Central Asia: more ‘cold’ than the others? Exploring (ethnic) identity under different sociopolitical settings

Kosmarskaya, Natalya

doi:10.1080/01434632.2013.845195

Cited by 11 publications

(1 citation statement)

References 17 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…The Russian language's role is often discussed in the literature in the context of ethnic Russians outside of Russia and has been presented as one of the primary identification factors (e.g., Laruelle & Peyrouse, 2007;Kosmarskaya, 2014;Cheskin & Kachuyevski, 2019). My research also confirms this assumption.…”

Section: Ethnic Heritage and Belongingness: Closing Thoughtssupporting

confidence: 76%

Imagining the desirable homeland: Nation-related belonging and social media use of young Kazakhstani Russians

Zhir-Lebed¹

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Recent events, such as the Ukrainian crisis, political protests in Belarus, and the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict’s escalation, have clearly demonstrated that the so-called ‘national question’ has remained an acute issue in the post-Soviet space. Being surrounded by Russia’s neo-imperial calls, but also by the dominating titular culture in the country of their current residence, ethnic Russians, and their national belonging arouse the interest of academia. Simultaneously, the tremendous expansion of information and communication technologies (ICTs), as well as the popularity of social media in the ex-Soviet republics, opens new opportunities for the conception of a national image, especially for young people. Hence, the studying of ethnic and civic belonging in the post-Soviet context requires an additional technological viewpoint. While Cyberspace in Kazakhstan remains state-controlled, Russia employs social media to unite its compatriots around the Russian national idea. However, the Internet may also support alternative identity constructions, grassroots movements, and the search for new national belongingness among ethnic minorities. How do young Kazakhstani Russians define their national belonging in the light of their social media usage? Which homeland do they imagine, and which role does Instagram play in this process? To answer these questions, I conducted explorative research, which was based upon a qualitative content analysis of 22 semi-structured interviews with young Kazakhstani Russians and a quantitative content analysis of local Instagram accounts. Interviewing ethnic Russians from big Kazakhstani cities demonstrated that these young people avoid formal national categories and creatively combine their multiple nation-related identities and belongings. Although social media content from Russia is present in their social media feeds, Ka-zakhstani Russians did not express any particular attachment to their historical “homeland.” Instead, they defined themselves as Kazakhstanis and advocated for ethnocultural pluralism and innovation inside and beyond Kazakhstan’s national borders. Their openness towards global cooperation is also reflected in their use of social media. At the same time, a close connection to a local space was widely relevant among Kazakhstani Russians. Posting Instagram stories from their everyday life, communicating with local friends, and consuming local news and event announcements, immersed young Kazakhstani Russians into the local city-related environment. Among the whole geographical and thematic content variety, following one or another urban account was an essential part of Kazakh-stani Russians’ social media use. As the Instagram analysis proved, textual and visual content on city-related accounts has blurred the boundaries between different discursive paradigms of national identity existing in Kazakhstan and presented the country in a positive light. In addition to other usage patterns, this provides an opportunity for these young people to construct a particular image of Kazakhstan, which helps them to find their social identity gratification and maintain positive self-esteem. As a result, their sense of belonging to Kazakhstan grows, allowing them to manage their multiple nation-related memberships while creating new categories beyond any formal definitions.

show abstract

Section: Ethnic Heritage and Belongingness: Closing Thoughtssupporting

confidence: 76%

Imagining the desirable homeland: Nation-related belonging and social media use of young Kazakhstani Russians

Zhir-Lebed¹

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

Still warm but getting colder: changing ethnic identity of post-Soviet Jewry

Nosenko-Stein

2013

Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Ethnic identity in post-Soviet Belarus: ethnolinguistic survival as an argument in the political struggle

Bekus

2013

Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This article discusses the Belarusian case of post-communist development and the role and status of Belarusian ethnicity in Belarus' nation-formation process. 'Nationalizing nationalism' (Brubaker), as realised by the Belarusian state through various social and cultural practices, is aimed at the creation of a Belarusian national entity without reference to the ethnocultural core of Belarusians. As a result of the nationalising practices of the Belarusian state, most Belarusians identify with their nation-state while displaying weak identification with ethnicity. At the same time, the recent dynamic of patterns of self-perception in Belarusian society can be interpreted as the beginning of a gradual 'heating' of the ethnocultural vitality of Belarusians, which is occurring under the impact of the agency of elites. Ethnolinguistic survival and vitality in this context can be viewed both as an argument in the struggle between different forces on the political arena and a factor contributing to victory in the rivalry between them. In this context, the phenomenon of 'ethnic temperature' can be analysed not only from the perspective of its impact on group vitality and survival, but also as a phenomenon dependent on various political, cultural and historical factors.

show abstract

Russians in post-Soviet Central Asia: more ‘cold’ than the others? Exploring (ethnic) identity under different sociopolitical settings

Cited by 11 publications

References 17 publications

Imagining the desirable homeland: Nation-related belonging and social media use of young Kazakhstani Russians

Imagining the desirable homeland: Nation-related belonging and social media use of young Kazakhstani Russians

Still warm but getting colder: changing ethnic identity of post-Soviet Jewry

Ethnic identity in post-Soviet Belarus: ethnolinguistic survival as an argument in the political struggle

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About