Rural emergency departments: A systematic review to develop a resource typology relevant to developed countries

Abstract

Objective Despite low patient numbers, rural emergency departments have a similar diversity of case presentations as urban tertiary hospitals, with the need to manage high‐acuity cases with limited resources. There are no consistent descriptions of the resources available to rural emergency departments internationally, limiting the capacity to compare clinical protocols and standards of care across similarly resourced units. This review aimed to describe the range of human, physical and specialist resources described in rural emergency departments in developed countries and propose a typology for use internationally. Design and setting A systematic literature search was performed for journal articles between 2000 and 2019 describing the staffing, access to radiology and laboratory investigations, and hospital inpatient specialists. Results Considerable diversity in defining rurality and in resource access was found within and between Australia, New Zealand, Canada and USA. Discussion A typology was developed to account for (a) emergency department staff on‐floor, (b) emergency department staff on‐call, (c) physical resources and (d) access to a specialist surgical service. This provides a valuable tool for relevant stakeholders to effectively communicate rural emergency department resources within a country and internationally. Conclusion The proposed five‐tiered typology draws together international literature regarding rural emergency department services. Although further research is required to test this tool, the formation of this common language allows a base for effective communication between governments, training providers and policy‐makers who are seeking to improve health systems and health outcomes.

Predictors of interhospital transfer delays in acute surgical patient deaths in Australia: a retrospective study

“…3 Facilities in rural regions were also substantially smaller with reduced levels of infrastructure that may not be adequate for managing all surgical emergencies. 3,6 The disparity of healthcare in regional Australia is a recognized problem, that has been difficult to address within the current healthcare system. The Australian healthcare system, Medicare, is a universal healthcare insurance scheme available to Australian citizens, permanent residents and countries with reciprocal agreements.…”

“…A lack of specialists was considered by patients in rural and remote regions to be the greatest barrier to accessing healthcare 3 . Facilities in rural regions were also substantially smaller with reduced levels of infrastructure that may not be adequate for managing all surgical emergencies 3,6 . The disparity of healthcare in regional Australia is a recognized problem, that has been difficult to address within the current healthcare system.…”

Acceptability of emergency department triage nurse's advice for patients to attend general practice: A cross‐sectional survey

“…28,29 Additionally, GPs may vary considerably in their own availability, resources and infrastructure, skill-mix and/or sub-specialisation, local population case-mix, demands, needs and dynamics such as availability of public transport and proximity to ancillary services. 30 The findings have implications for care coordination and patient navigation. The five factors identified that do influence the patient's confidence in the nurses' assessment may inform the…”

“…Some argue that using retrospective data fails to properly take into account a number of factors such as the patients' subjective views on the gravity of their conditions, patient's choice where to seek care and the actual and perceived local resource availability 28,29 . Additionally, GPs may vary considerably in their own availability, resources and infrastructure, skill‐mix and/or sub‐specialisation, local population case‐mix, demands, needs and dynamics such as availability of public transport and proximity to ancillary services 30 …”

Potential role of general practice in reducing emergency department demand: A qualitative study

“…Our research on the expanded role of PHC as a suitable alternative to the ED for acute care explored the factors influencing the growth in demand for emergency healthcare 2,5,10–13 . One of the research outcomes was the potential to divert demand to PHC, but that would require significant re‐engineering of PHC to meet patient needs 14 .…”