Romantic Re-Vision: Culture and Consciousness in Nineteenth-Century American Painting and Literature

Abstract

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. . College Art Association is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Art Bulletin. in order to challenge traditional interpretations of their role in American culture. He announces immediately in his preface that his enterprise is that of a critic and not of a historian. With a stance that is at once self-conscious and essentially "presentist," Wolf uses the modern critical vocabulary of structuralism, semiotics, psychoanalysis, and other "postmodern" ventures that emphasize the present perceiver's response to "texts" from the past. Wolf's responses to these artists' texts, he tells us, are shaped by the conviction that the past is neither recoverable nor worth trying to recover on its own terms. The past is valuable instead for what it will tell us about ourselves, in the terms we find most provocative in understanding ourselves: in Wolf's case, the language of structural patterns, cultural signs, and theories of the unconscious and repression. Throughout his text, Wolf cites the leading adapters of these viewpoints to cultural studies, among them Paul de Man, Roland Barthes, Michel Foucault, Harold Bloom, and Jacques Lacan, and such writers on artists as Michael Fried and Ronald Paulson.With its highly technical vocabulary, this book is not easy to read. In recasting Wolf's arguments below for the general reader, I remove them from the ideological context of their language, but not, I hope, from their essential meaning.Wolf proposes that in the early Romantic painting of Washington Allston, John Quidor, and Thomas Cole we can find the beginning of modernism in American art. Modernity, in Wolf's terms, is a characteristic of consciousness. The modern mind is torn by the irrecoverability of the past, the limits of language, and the unknowability of the world beyond what the self recreates in language. It was their preoccupation with these concerns that fueled the work of Allston, Quidor, and Cole, Wolf claims, not their interest in particular subject matter, or conventions, or even raw nature. Wolf suggests that these artists' emerging modernity was a signal of explicit as well as subterranean tensions in American society in the early 19th century.In Part One, titled "Romanticism and Self-Consciousness: Washington Allston," Wolf postulates the breakdown of Allston's faith in the dualism of the world, and thus in the referentiality of human thought (and paintings) to a reality outside the self. The first painting he examines closely is the artist's Portrait of Samuel Williams, before 1818, which shows the banker enclosed in a heavy architectural setting that opens at one point in the background to reveal an ideal landscape. Wolf reads the conventions...