Role of reading engagement in mediating effects of reading comprehension instruction on reading outcomes

Abstract

The engagement model of reading development suggests that instruction improves students' reading comprehension to the extent that it increases students' engagement processes in reading. We compared how Concept-Oriented Reading Instruction (CORI) (support for cognitive and motivational processes in reading), strategy instruction (support for cognitive strategies in reading), and traditional instruction in fourth-grade classrooms differentially influenced students' reading comprehension, strategy use, and engagement in reading. Students experiencing CORI were significantly higher than both comparison groups on reading comprehension, reading strategies, and reading engagement. When students' level of reading engagement was statistically controlled, the differences between the treatment groups were not significant. We infer that the level of students' reading engagement during classroom work mediated the instructional effects on reading outcomes. C 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.The engagement model of reading comprehension development proposes that engagement in reading is the joint functioning of motivational processes and cognitive strategies during reading comprehension (Guthrie & Wigfield, 2000). In this perspective, highly engaged readers are both internally motivated and strategic, and less engaged readers show lower motivation and less use of strategies for comprehending text. Consistent with this perspective, Fredricks, Blumenfeld, and Paris (2004) proposed that engagement is a multidimensional attribute including behavioral engagement (actively performing academic learning tasks), cognitive engagement (using high-level strategies to foster deep learning), and emotional engagement (enjoying academic tasks and expressing enthusiasm about learning). In this investigation, we examined the construct of engaged reading as a mediating variable that may account for the effect of integrated instruction on reading comprehension of elementary school students.Relatively few studies have attempted to increase reading engagement of elementary students experimentally or to examine the role of reading engagement in interventions that increase reading achievement. The few existing experimental studies of this age group have shown that at least four variables influence students' reading motivation: (a) autonomy support and choice, (b) use of interesting texts in classroom instruction, (c) having conceptual goals for reading instruction, and (d) supporting collaboration in reading. Guthrie and Humenick (2004) conducted a meta-analysis of the effects of these variables on reading motivation, identifying 22 studies that enabled 131 experimental comparisons to be made. Average effect sizes were 0.95 for choice, 0.72 for conceptual goals, 1.15 for providing interesting text, and 0.52 for collaboration. However, these studies were short term (1-6 hours), laboratory based (nonclassroom), with high teacher-pupil ratio (1-5) and limited materials (e.g., three 500-word passages), and thus have limited applicability to typical classroom...

The Interdependence between Young Students’ Reading Attitudes, Reading Skills, and Self-Esteem

“…A child who values reading wants to explore various literacy situations, and has reasons to use reading in a meaningful way. (Brozo, Shiel, & Topping, 2008;Wigfield & Barbosa, 2008.) As was mentioned above, boys' reading skills are not as good as girls' skills and girls succeed better than boys in every area of literacy.…”

Developing EFL Students’ Reading Comprehension and Reading Engagement: Effects of a Proposed Instructional Strategy

“…According to V. Vaish (2016) and Wigfield et al (2008) the term 'engagement' as a goal of teaching reading is consistent with a multi-dimensional approach in that it includes behavioral, emotional/motivational, and cognitive aspects. Thus, the engaged reader is assumed to be behaviorally active (reading frequently), internally motivated (liking to read), and cognitively active (uses strategies in reading).…”

Reading for meaning: the effects of Developmental Education on motivation and achievement in reading informative texts in primary school

“…The central pursuit of a recent innovative content approach, Concept-Oriented Reading Instruction (CORI), which was developed by Guthrie and Wigfield (2000), is to foster an in-depth understanding of the conceptual content of the text through the avenue of active engagement of the student. Extensive research has revealed that CORI interventions have positive effects on reading motivation and reading comprehension compared to approaches that are based on traditional or mere strategy instruction (Guthrie and Klauda 2014;Guthrie, McRae, and Klauda 2007;Guthrie et al 2004;Wigfield et al 2008).…”