Riding the Third Wave: Negotiating Teacher and Students’ Value Preferences Relating to Effective Mathematics Lesson

Abstract

The "Third Wave" is an ongoing international collaborative mathematics education research project, involving 10 countries conducted over the years [2009][2010][2011]. Adopting the theoretical framework of social cultural perspective, the project aimed to explore the contextually-bound understanding and meaning of what counts as effective mathematics lesson from both the teachers and pupils' perspectives. This paper will begin with a brief description of the Third Wave Study Project, the research framework and the general methodology used. Thereafter, it will concentrate on the main focus of the paper featuring a detailed discussion of the related findings from the Malaysian data. The data involved six mathematics teachers and 36 pupils from three types of primary schools. Multiple data sources were collected through classroom observations, photo-elicited focus group interviews with pupils and in-depth interviews with teachers. During each class lesson observation, the six selected pupils (as predetermined by their teacher) were given a digital camera to capture the moments or situations in the observed lesson that they perceived as effective. Pupils were then asked to elaborate what they meant by effective mathematics lesson based on the photographs that they have taken. Teachers were also interviewed individually immediately after each lesson observation and pupil's focus group interview. Findings of the study show that both teachers and pupils shared two co-values and two negotiated values in what they valued as an effective mathematics lesson. The two co-values are "board work" and "drill and practices" while the two negotiated values are "learning through mistakes" and "active student involvement". However, there are minor differences in teachers' and pupils' value preferences, for instance, pupils valued more of "clear explanation" from their teachers and active participation in classroom activities whereas teachers put emphasis on using different approaches to accommodate different types of pupils. More importantly, it was observed that an effective mathematics lesson is very much shaped by the continuous negotiation between

What Do Pāsifika Students in New Zealand Value Most for Their Mathematics Learning?

“…These responses indicated that students' perceived success and understanding in mathematics was achieved through hard work and practice. The results of the current study with Pāsifika students are broadly consistent with other values research from Europe and Asia (Lee and Seah 2015;Lim 2015;Österling and Andersson 2013) where students were reported to value effort and practice for their mathematics learning. This finding has important implications in challenging ongoing deficit perceptions and low expectations that many New Zealand teachers have towards their Pāsifika students (Rubie-Davies 2009.…”

“…We discovered that Pāsifika students' valued mathematics which was useful and/or practical for the present or future, and valued effort and practice as important for success in mathematics. The commonality of these two values across international research studies (e.g., Barkatas and Seah 2015;Lee and Seah 2015;Lim 2015;Österling and Andersson 2013) suggests these mathematics educational values are influenced by common societal and educational values.…”

An Intersection of Mathematics Educational Values and Cultural Values: Pāsifika Students’ Understanding and Explanation of Their Mathematics Educational Values

“…Evident in the student responses was the perception that to succeed in mathematics requires a personal effort. Earlier studies in different cultural contexts (e.g., Lim, 2015;Ö sterling & Andersson, 2013) have also indicated students' valuing of effort and practice in mathematical learning.…”

Values in Mathematics Learning: Perspectives of Chinese Mainland Primary and Secondary Students

“…In Hong Kong, junior students considered enjoyment, order, achievement, student involvement, teacher-led monitoring, and teacher support to be vital to the effective learning of mathematics (Law et al 2012). Malaysian primary students valued board work, exercise or practice, learning through mistakes, explanation and students' involvement as the five common elements of an effective mathematics lesson (Lim 2015). In Japan, fifth grade students tended to value process, effort, exploration, fact, openness and progress, whereas ninth grade students tended to value product, ability, exposition, idea, mystery, and control (Shinno et al 2014) suggesting students' values can change over time.…”