Rhythm and Cadence, Frenzy and March: Music and the Geo-Bio-Techno-Affective Assemblages of Ancient Warfare

Abstract

In one of many such passages in A Thousand Plateaus (hereafter "ATP") Deleuze and Guattari describe the assemblage as the imbrication of the social and the somatic, this time using an example from ancient Greek warfare:Assemblages [agencements] are passional, they are compositions of desire. Desire has nothing to do with a natural or spontaneous determination; there is no desire but assembling, assembled, desire [il n'y a de désir qu'agencant, agencé, machiné]. The rationality, the efficiency, of an assemblage does not exist without the passions the assemblage brings into play, without the desires that constitute it as much as it constitutes them. Detienne has shown that the Greek phalanx was inseparable from a whole reversal of values, and from a passional mutation that drastically changed the relations between desire and the war machine. It is a case of a man dismounting from the horse, and of the man-animal relation being replaced by a relation between men in an infantry assemblage that paves the way for the advent of the peasant-soldier, the citizen-soldier: the entire Eros of war changes, a group homosexual Eros tends to replace the zoosexual Eros of the horseman … Passions are effectuations of desire that differ according to the assemblage … Affect is the active discharge of emotion, the counterattack [la riposte], whereas feeling [le sentiment] is an always displaced, retarded, resisting emotion. 1 We are going to use this passage as a jumping-off point to examine some of the geo-bio-techno-affective assemblages at work in ancient Greek and Near Eastern warfare. We will look at the phalanx, but for greater contrast, we will not focus on the "zoosexual" horsemen, but on the berserker "runners" and their putative involvement in the 1200 BCE collapse of the Bronze Age kingdoms, of which Mycenae and Troy are the most famous examples. To describe these imbrications of the social and the somatic, I will use the term "body politic." 2 I have explored some dimensions of affect in contemporary military training; 3 here I am extending the analysis to ancient warfare.The article will have two parts. In Part 1, we're going to explore the ontology, biology, and history of affect. In each case we will put Deleuze and Guattari's work into the context of current research, primarily cognitive science, biology, anthropology, military history, and bio-cultural musicology. Exploring the ontology of affect will enable us to explain the exteriority of affect versus the interiority of emotion or "feeling." Exploring the biology of affect will take us to the biophilosophical school known as Developmental Systems Theory (DST) as it intersects new research in neuroscience. From this perspective, affective bodies are experientially constructed, and that experience is open to the social; it's a matter of variations on an inherited biological capacity for plasticity. In exploring the history of affect we will discuss cultural evolution and the anthropology of war. In Part 2, we are going to concentrate on the use of music in ancient ...

Affordances and the musically extended mind

“…3 Music can also coordinate actions both solitary and social. In elevating our mood and sharpening our attentional focus ( Sridharan et al, 2007 ), music can get us into different states of action-readiness necessary for various activities, including combat ( Gittoes, 2004 ; Protevi, 2010 ), athletics ( DeNora, 1986 ), erotic encounters ( DeNora, 1997 ), dining out ( Caldwell and Hibbert, 1999 ), or studying ( Rauscher et al, 1993 ).…”

Esprit de Corpsand thinking on (and with) your feet: Standard, enactive, and poststructuralist aspects of relational autonomy and collective intentionality in team sports

“…Here are some of the components of the bodily, affective underpinnings of the relational autonomy and collective intentionality interface in team sports. Touching (high‐fives, hugs, handshakes, pats on back) (Kraus et al, 2010) Entrainment (jogging/stretching, drill work in resonance) (McNeill, 1995) Mutual effort/exhaustion (beta‐endorphin‐dopamine connection along with association of fellow strivers) (Cohen et al, 2009; Davis et al, 2015; Machin & Dunbar, 2011) Joy in rhythmic movement (sport as exaptation of dance rooted in mother‐infant relation and lullaby) (Protevi, 2010; reprinted in Protevi, 2013)) Joy from joint attention/joint commitment (Hrdy, 2009; Tomasello, 2016) …”

“…Mutual effort/exhaustion (beta-endorphin-dopamine connection along with association of fellow strivers) (Cohen et al, 2009;Davis et al, 2015;Machin & Dunbar, 2011) 4. Joy in rhythmic movement (sport as exaptation of dance rooted in mother-infant relation and lullaby) (Protevi, 2010; reprinted in Protevi, 2013)) 5. Joy from joint attention/joint commitment (Hrdy, 2009;Tomasello, 2016) Feedback loops are evident here: if you like each other, you want to touch your teammates to encourage each other, which helps success, which helps liking each other.…”

Ontological security, circulations of affect, and the Arab Spring

“…Deleuze contends that the body is not a monolithic unit, but is itself a composition of various kinds of other bodies and relationships that continuously affects and is affected by other bodies. Affect, in this sense, is 'what a body can do and what it can undergo' (Protevi 2010). Or, as Deleuze and Guattari (2004: 283) contend, 'affects are becomings', where becoming is contrasted with more fixed 'being'.…”