Prior to the discovery in 1990 that mandelate racemase (MR) 1 and muconate-lactonizing enzyme (MLE) are structurally similar enzymes that catalyze different overall reactions (1), structurally related enzymes were assumed to catalyze identical chemical reactions but, perhaps, with distinct substrate specificities. For example, all of the members of the serine protease superfamily were known to catalyze the same chemistry, hydrolyses of peptide bonds, although their peptide substrates varied. As described by Craik and Perona in the previous minireview (2), evolutionary accommodation of these differences in substrate specificity can result in major reorganization of the associated structures.In this minireview, we discuss four recently discovered enzyme superfamilies in which an alternate theme predominates; within each of these superfamilies, the member proteins share a common structural scaffold but catalyze different overall reactions. For each of the superfamilies described, the active sites are contained within a single homologous domain. Although they represent several distinct family folds, the enzyme functions in each superfamily are related to their respective structural scaffolds in the same way; the proteins within each superfamily utilize a common mechanistic strategy for lowering the free energies of the rate-limiting transition states in the reactions they catalyze. The existence of several examples of such superfamilies lends further credence to the principle that the evolution of new catalytic activities involves the incorporation of new catalytic groups within an active site while retaining those groups necessary to catalyze the partial reaction common to all of them (3-5). As a consequence, the range of catalytic functions that can be accommodated by a single structural scaffold is considerably broader than had been previously suspected. Further, the diversity of function that each superfamily represents allows an economy in the number of unique protein folds required to support life and, as a result, undoubtedly has "simplified" the course of metabolic evolution.
The Enolase Superfamily: Abstraction of the ␣-Protons of Carboxylic AcidsWe recently described the enolase superfamily, the members of which catalyze at least 11 different chemical reactions, including racemization, epimerization, and both syn and anti -elimination reactions involving water, ammonia, or an intramolecular carboxylate group as leaving group (5).Despite broad differences in substrate structures and the overall reactions they catalyze, all of the reactions of the enolase superfamily are initiated by a common partial reaction, metal-assisted, general base-catalyzed abstraction of the ␣-proton of a carboxylate anion to generate a stabilized enolate anion intermediate (Reaction 1). However, the fate of the intermediate (protonation in the case of racemization and epimerization reactions and vinylogous -elimination in the others) must be determined by the different functional groups that "surround" the intermediate in the a...