Reviewing the State-of-the-Art of Smart Cities in Portugal: Evidence Based on Content Analysis of a Portuguese Magazine

Abstract

The lack of examples of smart-city initiatives and the sharing of best practices in Portugal confirm the gap in the transference of empirical knowledge to the scientific literature in this area. The smart-city concept has passed through three stages. However, its evolution has not been noted equally throughout countries and their territories. The literature only provides information about specific projects implemented in a few cities. Therefore, the aim of this paper was to study the state-of-the-art of smart cities in Portugal by analyzing 25 editions of the most relevant national-wide smart-cities magazine. First, the objective of analyzing the magazine was to study each Portuguese city in terms of the subject areas and types of existing initiatives in order, ultimately, to frame cities within their respective smart-city phases, as per the literature. Second, the aim of the paper was also to provide information about the evolution of the concept through analyses of embedded experts’ quotes. The results of the first are complemented with the analysis of interviews with policymakers to provide information about the existing challenges to implementing a smart city and to understand the role of government therein. Qualitative and quantitative analyses were performed on the case study. The findings suggest that the three smart-city phases are perceived in slightly different ways in Portugal and heterogeneity within the country can be noted from the lack of strategies and a standard framework.

A Review of the Theory and Practice of Smart City Construction in China

“…Such an approach primarily focuses on the role of technology in advancing urban development and construction [16]. Existing theories generally agree that large technology providers tend to play a leading role in the construction of smart cities at this stage, including IBM Corp [11], Songdo of the Republic of Korea [17][18][19], Portugal's PlanIT Valley [20,21], and China's Unicom [22,23]. The smart city operational model, which relies on IT support, data, and intelligent technologies, aims to upgrade industries, improve efficiency, and protect livelihoods.…”

A Bibliometric-Based Analytical Framework for the Study of Smart City Lifeforms in China

“…From the perspective of the theoretical development of a smart city, the theoretical connotation of a smart city and its technical support framework have undergone changes in specific practice. Smart City Version 1.0 is a smart urban solution promoted by technology companies; Smart City Version 2.0 is a local government solution leading the improvement of residents’ lives and sustainable lifestyles; Smart City Version 3.0 is a community collaboration model, which includes the best strategic solutions for citizens, policy makers, enterprises, and other subjects [ 5 ]. The development of smart city theory cannot be separated from the logic of specific technological developments, where technologies such as the Internet of Things, big data, and artificial intelligence have become the underlying framework supporting and influencing the connotative development of smart city theory, here including the theoretical categories of sustainability, innovation, and governance.…”

Multiple Smart Cities: The Case of the Eco Delta City in South Korea

“…There are various types of smart city literature across the world. Numerous scholars have focused on articulating the meaning of 'smart city' by connecting the concept with its practice [7,[18][19][20]. Through the smart technologies surrounding urban areas, Batty et al [21] argued that 'cities can only be smart if there are intelligence functions that are able to integrate and synthesise these data to some purpose.'…”