Review of third-wave therapies for substance use disorders in people of color and collectivist cultures: Current evidence and future directions.

Abstract

Objective: In people of color (POC) and from collectivist cultures, third-wave therapies utilizing mindfulness may be a more sensitive approach to substance use disorder (SUD) treatment, than cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). This systematic review examined this hypothesis. Method: We searched PsycINFO, Pubmed, and MEDLINE on December 23, 2021. Articles were included if they compared efficacy of third-wave therapies to therapies with only CBT elements and reported treatment outcomes for POC/people from collectivist cultures. Results: We included eleven studies conducted in the United States (n = 5), Spain (n = 2), Brazil (n = 2), Hong Kong (n = 1), and Iran (n = 1). Third-wave therapies included mindfulness-based relapse prevention (n = 4), acceptance and commitment therapy (n = 3), yoga and breathing strategies (n = 2), and mindfulness/emotion regulation training (n = 2). The substance use outcomes measured included nicotine use (n = 6), opioid use (n = 1), and general SUDs (n = 4) using biological measures (n = 7), Timeline Followback (n = 4), and the Addiction Severity Index (ASI; n = 2) to measure substance use. Overall, eight studies reported greater improvements in the third-wave therapy group relative to the CBT group in POC, on at least one substance use outcome. Conclusions: Findings suggest that relative to CBT, third-wave therapies are a promising modality in the treatment SUDs in POC and people and from collectivist cultures. However, studies are relatively sparse and carry a number of methodological problems. As such, there remains a need for further research.

A pilot study of experiencing racial microaggressions, obsessive-compulsive symptoms, and the role of psychological flexibility

“…In one of the first meta-analyses at the time, examining use of acceptance and mindfulnessbased treatments for people from diverse backgrounds related to refugee status, race, forensic, and older adults, Fuchs et al (2013) found small to large effect sizes depending on design and comparison condition, with overall small sample sizes, providing initial support but a need for future research. Other research and reviews have echoed that there is theoretical and research support for acceptance and mindfulness-based treatments for Black people and people of colour (POC), but overall there is a need for more studies with these treatments and populations (Dawson et al, 2022;Dela Cruz et al, 2022;Martinez et al, 2022b;Trefethen, 2019). MacIntyre et al (2023) reiterate the general need for new interventions to be validated to help people cope with anxiety disorders related to racism.…”

Testing the waters: A pilot trial of acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) for alcohol use disorder

“…[ 6 ] Evidence suggests that ACT might be more effective in collectivist cultures. [ 13 ] However, none of the previous studies were from the South East Asian region, representing such culture.…”