Borohydride (BH 4 − ) is a ubiquitous reducing agent in chemistry despite its apparent inability to transfer hydride fragments without assistance. In protic solvents such as methanol, B−H protonolysis and H 2 evolution furnish borane, which serves as the key hydride delivery agent in the reduction of cyclohexanone. Contrasting with widely accepted but inaccessible mechanisms involving direct (intermolecular) hydride transfer from BH 4 − , in this work, DFT calculations performed in close conjunction with H/D exchange studies unambiguously justify the use of alcohol as a necessary evil that renders substantial kinetic advantages in intramolecular hydride transfer, albeit requiring excess BH 4 − to compensate for the protonolytic loss of available B−H fragments as H 2 .