Visual loss associated with allergic fungal sinusitis (AFS) is uncommon, with incidence estimates ranging from 1.46% to 3.7%. Uncertainty remains concerning the pathophysiology of visual loss in the setting of AFS. Proposed theories include direct or indirect compression of the optic nerve or orbital inflammatory changes causing an optic neuritis. A case of precipitous visual loss in an adult male with clinical and radiographic evidence of optic neuropathy is reported. After surgical and medical interventions this patient showed improvement in optic nerve function. Visual loss associated with AFS is a rare but potentially devastating condition.