Hyperkalemia is a complex laboratory abnormality. There are varying degrees of true hyperkalemia, pseudohyperkalemia, and even reverse pseudohyperkalemia which must be distinguished from one another. We present a case of reverse pseudohyperkalemia in an elderly male with a hematologic malignancy found to have an elevated potassium level on admission. Both plasma and serum levels were measured, plasma level was high while serum levels were normal, and a diagnosis of reverse pseudohyperkalemia was made. Awareness and increased suspicion result in rapid diagnosis, and prevent overtreatment and iatrogenic complications.