Rethinking retention: Mapping interactions between multiple factors that influence long-term engagement in HIV care

Abstract

BackgroundFailure to keep people living with HIV engaged in life-long care and treatment has serious implications for individual and population-level health. Nested within a four-province study of HIV care and treatment outcomes, we explored the dynamic role of social and service-related factors influencing retention in HIV care in Zambia.MethodsFrom a stratified random sample of 31 facilities, eight clinics were selected, one urban and one rural from each province. Across these sites we conducted a total of 69 in-depth interviews, including with patients (including pregnant women) engaged in-care (n = 28), disengaged from care (n = 15), engaged facility transferee (n = 12), and friends/family of deceased patients (n = 14). At the same sites we conducted 24 focus group discussions with a total of 192 lay and professional healthcare workers (HCWs). Two-day observations in each of the eight facilities helped triangulate data on operational context, provider relations and patient-provider interactions. We ordered and analysed data using an adapted version of Ewart’s Social Action Theory.ResultsThree overarching findings emerged. First, the experience of living with HIV and engaging in HIV care in Zambia is a social, not individual experience, influenced by social and gendered norms and life goals including financial stability, raising family and living stigma-free. Second, patients and their networks act collectively to negotiate and navigate HIV care. Anticipated responses from social network influenced patients’ willingness to engage in care, while emotional and material support from those networks influenced individuals’ capacity to remain in HIV care. Lastly, health system factors were most influential where they facilitated or undermined peoples’ collective approach to health service use. Participants living with HIV reported facilitation of both their initial and continued engagement in care where services involved social networks, such as during couples testing and community outreach. Conversely, service features that were poorly aligned with respondents’ social reality (e.g. workplace obligations) hindered long-term engagement.ConclusionsThis study moves beyond listing barriers or socio-ecological groupings, to explain how social and health systems interact to produce HIV care outcomes. Our findings challenge the implicit assumption of individual agency underpinning many retention studies to highlight the social nature of illness and healthcare utilization for HIV in Zambia. This understanding of collective action for accessing and remaining in HIV care should underpin future efforts to revise and reform HIV and potentially other chronic service models and systems.

STACKing the odds for adolescent survival: health service factors associated with full retention in care and adherence amongst adolescents living with HIV in South Africa

“…Two ongoing randomized trials in South Africa and Uganda examine family‐based and economic strengthening approaches to adherence support, and successful pilots suggest likely positive impacts . Recent qualitative research with adult HIV patients in Zambia finds that experiences of health systems interact closely with patient characteristics and the social settings in which they negotiate their ART use . It will be important to further identify how social and economic services can support health services to improve adolescent retention in HIV care.…”

Understanding preferences for HIV care and treatment in Zambia: Evidence from a discrete choice experiment among patients who have been lost to follow-up

“…We used qualitative research as well as a literature review to select attributes to include in the DCE [ 12 ]. Qualitative interviews were conducted with patients to assess facilitators and barriers to engagement in care in Zambia and are described in a separate manuscript [ 12 ]. Emergent themes were discussed with local stakeholders and healthcare workers.…”

‘They care rudely!’: resourcing and relational health system factors that influence retention in care for people living with HIV in Zambia

“… 37 Analysis more specifically considering the manner in which various individual, social and health system factors interact to influence engagement decisions has been previously published. 38 …”