Responsibility for Each Other's Freedom: Agency as the Source of Collective Capability

Abstract

This paper tries to extend Sen's capability approach by introducing the issues of personal responsibility and collective capability, in addition to those of individual capability and collective responsibility. In addressing the issue of the subject's responsibility, we turn to the phenomenological tradition. This approach uses the concept of the person rather than that of the individual. In the analytical philosophy tradition the individual�is defined by a set of freedoms and capabilities. The phenomenological approach, in contrast, views the person as embedded in a network of social relationships that determine a set of rights and obligations. In most situations, personal obligations have to be satisfied before the person can move on to satisfy his/her rights and freedoms. This means that freedom is viewed as being derived from responsibility, thus inversing the order of the capability approach. The subject's responsibility becomes fundamental, and a part of the 'richness' of the person. Responsibility expresses the capability to feel and be responsible, not only ex-post (i.e. once freedom has been exercised), but also ex-ante, by the capacity to exercise self-constraint on a voluntary basis in order to satisfy one's obligations towards others. Within his or her structure of capabilities, the person has to manage the twofold interacting sets of freedoms and responsibilities during the decision-making process. When we consider the person's agency, introducing responsibility leads, via commitment and social interactions, to a stronger vision of agency. However, this vision, which includes responsibility and social interactions, generates a collective capability that can be represented by a structure composed of the various personal capability structures.Agency, Collective capability, Person, Responsibility, Social sustainability,

Capacidades socio-estatales para la democracia local en contextos de violencia en Colombia y México

“…En esa línea de investigación, diversas etiquetas han sido propuestas: 'capacidades colectivas' (Evans, 2002;Ibrahim, 2006), 'capacidad relacional' (Ballet, Dubois & Mahieu, 2007), 'capacidades de grupo' (Stewart, 2005) y 'capacidades externas' (Foster & Handy, 2008). Todos estos autores coinciden en subrayar el carácter relacional de la vida en sociedad, y cómo algunas capacidades sólo pueden lograrse socialmente, además de profundizar en el análisis de las estructuras sociales, su peso en la agencia individual, así como las posibilidades transformadoras y expansivas de las capacidades (Crocker & Robeyns, 2010;Ballet, Dubois & Mahieu, 2007;Griewald & Rauschmayer, 2014;Rauschmayer, Bauler & Schäpke, 2015;Pelenc, Bazile & Ceruti, 2015, Pelenc & Ballet, 2015.…”

Enhancing pro-public-good professionalism in technical studies

“…The second element is the responsibility towards others. Ballet et al (2007) propose to broaden Sen's concept of agency by considering responsibility as a constitutive characteristic of the person at the same level as freedom. This has important consequences as it generates a distinction between weak and strong agency.…”

Work-Life Reconciliation Policies from Well-Being to Development: Rethinking EU Gender Mainstreaming

“…They offer a sort of "mosaic" of multiple explanations, based on the assumption that initial conditions matter because agents (in backward areas) "do not always avail themselves of the best opportunities afforded to them" (Banerjee, Duflo, 2005:). We take into account this broad literature, by selecting essentially two strands, one is related to poverty traps and the other to the agents' aspirations (Appadurai 2002;Ray, 2002).…”

“…The modern theory of growth (Banerjee, Duflo 2005;Venables, Burgess, 2004) and the "frontiers of development economics" (Meier, Stiglitz, 2002;Ray, 1998Ray, , 2000 suggest categories and heuristics, which seem useful to build our cognitive framework. They offer a sort of "mosaic" of multiple explanations, based on the assumption that initial conditions matter because agents (in backward areas) "do not always avail themselves of the best opportunities afforded to them" (Banerjee, Duflo, 2005:).…”

“…If these assumptions are correct, the level of skilled labour demand and supply remains low, because of the growing returns on investments in education. A second class of models deals with the role played by institutions and various types of government failure (Banerjee, Duflo 2005;). These types of failure have the effect of distorting private investment decisions because of too high or too low levels of protection.…”