Response to “Comment on ‘Electric field measurements under DC corona discharges in ambient air by electric field induced second harmonic generation’” [Appl. Phys. Lett. 117, 026101 (2020)]

A practical guide to modeling low-current quasi-stationary gas discharges: Eigenvalue, stationary, and time-dependent solvers

“…29: the electric field distribution in a negative corona in an axially symmetric concentric-cylinder gap in air, computed by means of a steady-state model, was shown to be in good agreement with the time-averaged measurements, 30 performed in a regime with repetitive Trichel pulses. 31 Thus, in the case of a pulsed corona, time-dependent solvers, while being an adequate tool for studies of spatiotemporal evolution of individual pulses (e.g., Refs. [31][32][33][34][35], cannot be used for the direct calculation of time-averaged characteristics of the discharge.…”

“…31 Thus, in the case of a pulsed corona, time-dependent solvers, while being an adequate tool for studies of spatiotemporal evolution of individual pulses (e.g., Refs. [31][32][33][34][35], cannot be used for the direct calculation of time-averaged characteristics of the discharge. The latter can be conveniently computed by means of stationary solvers in the framework of the integrated approach being used in this section.…”