Two tests were used to measure response recall in the A-B, A-C, the A-B, D-C (stimuli of both lists consisted of nonsense syllables), and the A-B, N-C (second-list stimuli constructed of numbers rather than nonsense syllables as in the first list) transfer paradigms and in a single-list control condition. Both recall tests required 5s to produce response terms from previously learned lists: one, free recall (FR), in the absence of stimulus terms; the other, modified-modified free recall (MMFR), in the presence of relevant stimulus terms. The type of measure of first-list response recall had a differential effect on the four conditions such that control, A-B, A-C, and A-B, N-C paradigms were influenced less by the type of recall test than the A-B, D-C paradigm, which showed significantly less response recall on FR than on MMFR. Results are discussed in terms of hypothetical sources of unlearning in the different paradigms.