Resonances for activity waves in spherical mean field dynamos

Abstract

Context. It has been suggested that resonant phenomena may play a role in determining the properties of mean-field dynamos, such as operate in the Sun and other stars. Aims. We tried to identify resonances which are expected to occur when a mean-field dynamo excites waves of quasi-stationary magnetic field in two distinct spherical layers. Methods. We used a model with two physically separated dynamo active layers to study activity waves of the kind that determine cyclic magnetic activity of various stars, including the Sun, as a more general physical rather than a purely astronomical problem. Results. We isolated some features that can be associated with resonances in the profiles of energy or frequency plotted versus a dynamo governing parameter. Rather unexpectedly however the resonances in spherical dynamos take a much less spectacular form than resonances in many more familiar branches of physics. In particular, we found that the magnitudes of resonant phenomena are much smaller than seem detectable by astronomical observations, and that plausibly any related effects in laboratory dynamo experiments (which of course are not in gravitating spheres!) can also be inferred to be likely to be small. Conclusions. We discuss specific features relevant to resonant phenomena in spherical dynamos, and find parametric resonance to be the most pronounced type of resonance phenomena. Resonance conditions for these dynamo wave resonances are rather different from those found in more conventional branches of physics. We suggest that the relative insignificance of the phenomenon in this situation is because the phenomena of excitation and propagation of the activity waves are not well-separated from each other and this, together with the nonlinear nature of more-or-less realistic dynamos, suppresses the resonances and makes them much less pronounced than the resonant effects found, for example, in optics.

Parity fluctuations in stellar dynamos

“…The magnetic energy and the ratio between the energy in toroidal and poloidal magnetic fields do not demonstrate any unusual behaviour that could be attributed to resonant effects. Here the results are similar to those obtained previously by Moss & Sokoloff (2013) earlier. The novelty is in the unusual behaviour of the parity, which appears chaotic if not quasiperiodic.…”

The solar dynamo: Inferences from observations and modeling

“…Relations between the fluctuations spectrum and parameters of simulated grand minima remains to be understood. The standard parametric resonance -including its stochastic version -does not exist in dynamos (Schmitt & Rüdiger 1992;Moss & Sokoloff 2013). Parametric excitation of irregularities in magnetic cycles hides still unknown physics.…”

Parametric modulation of dynamo waves

“…Schmitt & Rüdiger (1992) and Moss (1996) studied the parametric resonance for galactic dynamos. Gilman & Dikpati (2011) and Moss & Sokoloff (2013) considered the resonance phenomena for stellar convective dynamos. An interesting version of parametric resonance in nonlinear dynamos was found by Reshetnyak (2010): the resonance can result from a time-delay in the reaction of dynamo-parameters to the generated magnetic field.…”