Rereading Durkheim in light of Jewish law: how a traditional rabbinic thought-model shapes his scholarship

Abstract

When studying the work of Émile Durkheim, scholars must consider how his intellectual development in a traditional Jewish environment contributed to and informed his ideas. This article details how Durkheim’s upbringing endowed him with a traditional rabbinic thought-model. The author analyzes five of Durkheim’s major works to argue that the system of classification, language, and style of argument Durkheim used to define concepts in his scholarship mirror streams of rabbinic thought. The article builds off the sociology of knowledge to illuminate how Durkheim employed his codified knowledge of biblical texts and modern Jews to bolster his arguments, and reveals the subtler ways he demonstrates his tacit knowledge of the texts and argument styles. The article ends with an exploration of how conceptual frameworks from the sociology of knowledge may be applied to other leading sociological thinkers—how the modes of thinking instilled during formative years may orient scholarship and the benefits and limitations of this approach.

rasgos de sacralidad del liderazgo

“…80-81, 148). Este "segundo nacimiento", al decir de Winfield (2020), permite que el sujeto pase a formar parte plenamente de la nueva clase sagrada y tome distancia del estado anterior (p. 581).…”

The Unfinished Business of Erving Goffman: From Marginalization Up Towards the Elusive Center of American Sociology

“…The given distribution of "median household incomes", for example, is offered either as evidence of the importance of the supposedly more or less valuable "contributions to society" of those earning those incomes, or as evidence of unfair "discrimination" depending upon the student's choice between a "functionalist" or "conflict" standpoint. These alternative explanations raise questions about who decides what jobs 1 Winfield recently published a very helpful paper about Emile Durkheim's mindset and religious sources of information and inspiration (Winfield, 2020). 2 Wikipedia, refers to (Fine and Manning, 2003;Winkin, 1988) and several other sources.…”