Noncanonical
amino acid (ncAA) incorporation has led to significant
advances in protein science and engineering. Traditionally, in vivo incorporation of ncAAs is achieved via amber codon suppression using an engineered orthogonal aminoacyl-tRNA
synthetase:tRNA pair. However, as more complex protein products are
targeted, researchers are identifying additional barriers limiting
the scope of currently available ncAA systems. One barrier is elongation
factor Tu (EF-Tu), a protein responsible for proofreading aa-tRNAs,
which substantially restricts ncAA scope by limiting ncaa-tRNA delivery
to the ribosome. Researchers have responded by engineering ncAA-compatible
EF-Tus for key ncAAs. However, this approach fails to address the
extent to which EF-Tu inhibits efficient ncAA incorporation. Here,
we demonstrate an alternative strategy leveraging computational analysis
to broaden EF-Tu’s substrate specificity. Evolutionary analysis
of EF-Tu and a naturally evolved specialized elongation factor, SelB,
provide the opportunity to engineer EF-Tu by targeting amino acid
residues that are associated with functional divergence between the
two ancient paralogues. Employing amber codon suppression, in combination
with mass spectrometry, we identified two EF-Tu variants with non-native
substrate compatibility. Additionally, we present data showing these
EF-Tu variants contribute to host organismal fitness, working cooperatively
with components of native and engineered translation machinery. These
results demonstrate the viability of our computational method and
lend support to corresponding assumptions about molecular evolution.
This work promotes enhanced polyspecific EF-Tu behavior as a viable
strategy to expand ncAA scope and complements ongoing research emphasizing
the importance of a comprehensive approach to further expand the genetic
code.