Reproducibility in Ultrasonic Characterization of Carotid Plaques

Abstract

Background and Purpose: Echolucent carotid plaques compared with echogenic plaques could carry a significant risk of transient ischemic attacks and strokes, but the reproducibility of new ultrasonic methods has not yet been proved. The objective was to evaluate interobserver and intraobserver agreement in characterizing the carotid plaques studied by both B mode imaging and color Doppler imaging, which is the only ultrasonic method available for recognizing anechoic lesions. Methods: Fifty-three carotid plaques greater than 40% in diameter were selected from four centers and simultaneously analyzed by 9 observers. Five types of plaques were defined by their echo structure: class I = uniformly anechogenic, class II = predominantly hypoechogenic with >50% hypoechogenic area, class III = predominantly echogenic with >50% echogenic area, class IV = uniformly echogenic, class V = unclassified plaques. The luminal surface was characterized as either 1 = regular, 2 = recess of more than 2 mm in depth and width, or 3 = unclassified. Agreement of these variables was calculated by using the kappa index, agreement proportion and an intraclass correlation coefficient. Results: Interobserver reproducibility was only fair for type I (kappa = 0.47) and for the luminal surface (class 1, kappa = 0.52 and class 2, kappa = 0.41). Agreement proportion was 0.51 in hypoechoic plaques and 0.64 in the determination of the regular surface. Mean intraobserver agreement was fair (kappa = 0.47 ± 0.1) for plaque echogenicity to good (kappa = 0.63 ± 0.19) for surface. Conclusion: This study shows that the semiquantitative classification, first developed by Gray-Weale, then by Nicolaides, could be improved, thus giving rise to a new outlook in the debated field of ulcerations.

Early Activation of Intracranial Collateral Vessels Influences the Outcome of Spontaneous Internal Carotid Artery Dissection

“…We enrolled 66 patients with a first-ever ischemic stroke who clinically showed a large-artery infarction 10 and ultrasonographic (Philips IU22 ultrasound system) evidence of ipsilateral ICA occlusion [11][12][13] due to arterial dissection detected within 12 hours from symptom onset. All subjects underwent (1) brain and neck magnetic resonance angiography combined with T1-weighted axial cervical magnetic resonance scans with the fat-saturation technique required to confirm the diagnosis of arterial dissection 14 ; (2) brain computed tomography; (3) careful neurologic evaluation; (4) cardiologic examination, ECG, and transthoracic echocardiography to rule out cardioembolic sources; and (5) complete blood chemistry analysis, including homocysteine.…”

Soluble TWEAK and Major Adverse Cardiovascular Events in Patients with CKD

“…The analysis included both carotid and femoral arteries. To determine plaque calcification, a semiquantitative method previously described by de Bray et al (24) was used.…”

Volume of Carotid Artery Ulceration as a Predictor of Cardiovascular Events

“…15 Fisher et al 16 found that histologically validated ulceration was more common in endarterectomy specimens from patients with symptomatic carotid stenosis versus asymptomatic stenosis. De Bray et al 17 found that the reproducibility of detection of ulceration by 2D ultrasound was only 0.41. Schminke et al 5 reported that they could reliably follow progression or regression of ulceration by 3D ultrasound.…”