Reply to “Reply to comments on defining biominerals and organominerals: Direct and indirect indicators of life [Perry et al., Sedimentary Geology, 201, 157–179]” by R.S. Perry and M.A. Sephton
Abstract:This is a reply to R.S. Perry and M.A. Sephton's "Reply to comments on defining biominerals and organominerals: direct and indirect indicators of life [Perry et al., Sedimentary Geology, 201, 157-179]" [Sedimentary Geology 213 (2009) 156].
“…These diverse processes are still being elucidated, and the terminology used in biocalcification and biomineralization studies continues to evolve. In addition to ‘bioinduced’ and ‘biocontrolled’, researchers examining how organic macromolecules and environmental conditions interact to influence mineralization have suggested ‘organomineralization’ (Trichet & Défarge, ) and ‘organomineral’ (Défarge & Trichet, ; Perry et al ., ), and ‘biologically influenced mineralization’ (Dupraz et al ., ; Perito & Mastromei, ); sometimes prompting spirited debate (Altermann et al ., ; Défarge et al ., , ; Perry & Sephton, ). Reef‐building coralline algae (Kamenos et al ., ) and invertebrates, including corals (Puverel et al ., ; Allemand et al ., ; Moya et al ., ), display relatively controlled calcification (Orr et al ., ; Kleypas et al ., ).…”
Ocean acidification by atmospheric carbon dioxide has increased almost continuously since the last glacial maximum (LGM), 21,000 years ago. It is expected to impair tropical reef development, but effects on reefs at the present day and in the recent past have proved difficult to evaluate. We present evidence that acidification has already significantly reduced the formation of calcified bacterial crusts in tropical reefs. Unlike major reef builders such as coralline algae and corals that more closely control their calcification, bacterial calcification is very sensitive to ambient changes in carbonate chemistry. Bacterial crusts in reef cavities have declined in thickness over the past 14,000 years with largest reduction occurring 12,000-10,000 years ago. We interpret this as an early effect of deglacial ocean acidification on reef calcification and infer that similar crusts were likely to have been thicker when seawater carbonate saturation was increased during earlier glacial intervals, and thinner during interglacials. These changes in crust thickness could have substantially affected reef development over glacial cycles, as rigid crusts significantly strengthen framework and their reduction would have increased the susceptibility of reefs to biological and physical erosion. Bacterial crust decline reveals previously unrecognized millennial-scale acidification effects on tropical reefs. This directs attention to the role of crusts in reef formation and the ability of bioinduced calcification to reflect changes in seawater chemistry. It also provides a long-term context for assessing anticipated anthropogenic effects.
“…These diverse processes are still being elucidated, and the terminology used in biocalcification and biomineralization studies continues to evolve. In addition to ‘bioinduced’ and ‘biocontrolled’, researchers examining how organic macromolecules and environmental conditions interact to influence mineralization have suggested ‘organomineralization’ (Trichet & Défarge, ) and ‘organomineral’ (Défarge & Trichet, ; Perry et al ., ), and ‘biologically influenced mineralization’ (Dupraz et al ., ; Perito & Mastromei, ); sometimes prompting spirited debate (Altermann et al ., ; Défarge et al ., , ; Perry & Sephton, ). Reef‐building coralline algae (Kamenos et al ., ) and invertebrates, including corals (Puverel et al ., ; Allemand et al ., ; Moya et al ., ), display relatively controlled calcification (Orr et al ., ; Kleypas et al ., ).…”
Ocean acidification by atmospheric carbon dioxide has increased almost continuously since the last glacial maximum (LGM), 21,000 years ago. It is expected to impair tropical reef development, but effects on reefs at the present day and in the recent past have proved difficult to evaluate. We present evidence that acidification has already significantly reduced the formation of calcified bacterial crusts in tropical reefs. Unlike major reef builders such as coralline algae and corals that more closely control their calcification, bacterial calcification is very sensitive to ambient changes in carbonate chemistry. Bacterial crusts in reef cavities have declined in thickness over the past 14,000 years with largest reduction occurring 12,000-10,000 years ago. We interpret this as an early effect of deglacial ocean acidification on reef calcification and infer that similar crusts were likely to have been thicker when seawater carbonate saturation was increased during earlier glacial intervals, and thinner during interglacials. These changes in crust thickness could have substantially affected reef development over glacial cycles, as rigid crusts significantly strengthen framework and their reduction would have increased the susceptibility of reefs to biological and physical erosion. Bacterial crust decline reveals previously unrecognized millennial-scale acidification effects on tropical reefs. This directs attention to the role of crusts in reef formation and the ability of bioinduced calcification to reflect changes in seawater chemistry. It also provides a long-term context for assessing anticipated anthropogenic effects.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.