Most anticancer drugs entering clinical trials fail to achieve approval from the US FDA. Drug development is hampered by the lack of preclinical models with therapeutic predictive value. Herein, we report the development and validation of a tumorgraft model of renal cell carcinoma (RCC) and its application to the evaluation of an experimental drug. Tumor samples from 94 patients were implanted in the kidney of mice without additives or disaggregation. Tumors from 35 patients formed tumorgrafts, and 16 stable lines were established. Samples from metastatic sites engrafted at high frequency, and stable engraftment of primary tumors in mice correlated with decreased patient survival suggesting that tumor growth in mice may reveal the acquisition by the tumor of an ability to thrive at distant sites and metastasize. Tumorgrafts retained the histology, gene expression, DNA copy number alterations, and over 90% of the protein-coding gene mutations of the corresponding tumors. As determined by the induction of hypercalcemia in tumorgraft-bearing mice, tumorgrafts were able to act on the host causing paraneoplastic syndromes. In studies simulating drug exposures in patients, RCC tumorgraft growth was inhibited by sunitinib and sirolimus (into which temsirolimus is converted in humans), but not by erlotinib, which was used as a control. Dovitinib, a drug in clinical development, showed greater activity than sunitinib and sirolimus. The routine incorporation of models recapitulating the molecular genetics and drug sensitivities of human tumors into preclinical programs has the potential to improve oncology drug development.