Reliability of goniometric measurements in children with cerebral palsy: A comparative analysis of universal goniometer and electronic inclinometer. A pilot study

Abstract

BackgroundEven though technological progress has provided us with more and more sophisticated equipment for making goniometric measurements, the most commonly used clinical tools are still the universal goniometer and, to a lesser extent, the inclinometer. There is, however, no published study so far that uses an inclinometer for measurements in children with cerebral palsy (CP). The objective of this study was two-fold: to independently assess the intra and inter-examiner reliability for measuring the hip abduction range of motion in children with CP using two different instruments, the universal two-axis goniometer and electronic inclinometer. A pool of 5 examiners with different levels of experience as paediatric physiotherapists participated. The study did not compare both instruments because the measurement procedure and the hip position were different for each.MethodsA prospective, observational study of goniometery was carried out with 14 lower extremities of 7 children with spastic CP. The inclinometer study was carried out with 8 lower extremities of 4 children with spastic CP. This study was divided into two independent parts: a study of the reliability of the hip abduction range of motion measured with a universal goniometer (hip at 0° flexion) and with an electronic inclinometer (hip at 90° flexion). The Intraclass Correlation Coefficient (ICC) was calculated to analyse intra and inter-examiner agreement for each instrument.ResultsFor the goniometer, the intra-examiner reliability was excellent (>0.80), while the inter-examiner reliability was low (0.375 and 0.475). For the inclinometer, both the intra-examiner (0.850-0.975) and inter-examiner reliability were excellent (0.965 and 0.979).ConclusionsThe inter-examiner reliability for goniometric measurement of hip abduction in children with CP was low, in keeping with other results found in previous publications. The inclinometer has proved to be a highly reliable tool for measuring the hip abduction range of motion in children with CP, which opens up new possibilities in this field, despite having some measurement limitations.

Correlation between hip function and knee kinematics evaluated by three-dimensional motion analysis during lateral and medial side-hopping

“…Co. Ltd., Japan), was used. ROM measurements for extension in supine position and internal/external rotation (IR/ER) in prone position were performed using this device28, 29 ) . Each measurement was performed three times and the maximum value of the three measurements was adopted.…”

Determining the Reliability of a New Method for Measuring Joint Range of Motion Through a Randomized Controlled Trial

“…For the hip, a range of ICCs were reported. Herrero et al [32] reported excellent (>0.80) intra-rater reliability and low (0.375 and 0.475) inter-rater reliability. Poulsen et al [33] found moderate inter-rater reliability for goniometric hip ROM measurement.…”

The effects of kinesio taping of lower limbs on functional mobility, spasticity, and range of motion of children with spastic cerebral palsy

“…In this study, ROM in dorsi flexion and knee extension were estimated and recorded via a triangle (set square) meter. Herrero and colleagues analyzed the reliability of the triangle meter in cerebral palsy children and concluded that pre-and posttest reliabilities were good; however, intertester reliability was weak [11].…”