Reliability of chest radiograph interpretation for pulmonary tuberculosis in the screening of childhood TB contacts and migrant children in the UK

Abstract

To determine interobserver agreement between paediatric radiologists interpreting tuberculosis (TB) screening chest radiographs (CXR) in children in the UK, and the TB detection rate.MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective review was undertaken of electronic request, notes, and CXRs (>7 years) in children exposed to an infectious case of TB and new entrants to the UK, at a tertiary children's hospital. Included were those with positive Mantoux/interferon gamma release assay (IGRA), positive culture, or high clinical suspicion of TB. CXR reports were categorised as normal, abnormal without features of TB, or abnormal with features of pulmonary TB. Three paediatric radiologists from a dedicated paediatric radiology department evaluated available CXRs, aware of the TB screening indication, using a published CXR reporting tool and blinded to the initial CXR report and to each other. A majority decision was collated, and considered lymphadenopathy and miliary nodules as diagnostic of primary TB. Interobserver agreement was calculated using Cohen's kappa.RESULTS: One hundred and forty-eight children underwent TB screening with a CXR. One hundred and twenty-five had available CXR reports and case notes, which indicated 20/125 (16%) had CXR features of TB. One hundred and twenty-one of the 125 had CXRs available to for panel review. Twenty of these 121 (17%) yielded a majority decision of pulmonary TB. Interreader agreement was moderate in all aspects (kappa 0.4e0.6).CONCLUSION: The high percentage of pulmonary TB on CXR (16% original reports; 17% by panel review) suggests that it is worthwhile investigating childhood TB contacts; however, the

Diagnosis and Management of Childhood Tuberculosis: A Cross-Sectional Study of Practices in Gilgit Baltistan, Pakistan

“…In 2021 Khuawar et al, while studying Tuberculosis as a forecaster of childhood malnutrition in Sindh, Pakistan observed that 13% children infected with TB were found with low BMI and low nutrition marker [26]. In our study almost all physicians reported asking for X-ray chest for diagnosis of pulmonary TB.In contrast, in 2020 a study conducted by Andronikou et al, in UK suggests the routine practice for chest X-ray is disputed because of only moderate reliability [27]. In our study majority physicians prescribed investigations including complete blood count (CBC) and erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR).…”

Chest X-Ray–Based Telemedicine Platform for Pediatric Tuberculosis Diagnosis in Low-Resource Settings: Development and Validation Study

“…Similarly, Berteloot et al [28] reported a kappa value of 0.36 between radiologist and pediatric pulmonologist. Lastly, Andronikou et al [29] presented a kappa value of 0.5 between trained pediatric radiologists, although their dataset included older children with a mean age of 9 years old.…”

Pulmonary tuberculosis risks and challenges

“…Although the risk of developing TB is low in most developed countries, the risk of infection increases with age [28]. There is an estimated likelihood that one in twenty-five people will develop active TB during their lifetimes in the United States [29]. There are approximately 140 cases of tuberculosis per 100,000 people in South Africa every year, making it one of the highest rates in the world [30].…”