Reliability of Attachment Level Measurements Using the Cementoenamel Junction and a Plastic Stent

Abstract

Repeated measurements of attachment level appear to be important assessments in periodontal clinical trials, yet the lack of reliability for this assessment creates measurement error which in turn demands increased sample sizes or reduces the power of the test. A plastic occlusal stent has been developed as a fixed reference point to assess changes in probing depths over time and thus reflect differences in attachment levels. The advantages of this system over traditional methods have not been measured. The purpose of this study was to determine intra- and interexaminer reliability for probing depths from the stent and the CEJ. Paired measurements of attachment level using the stent produced correlation coefficients for inter- and intraexaminer readings of 0.84 and 0.76, respectively. For subgingival cementoenamel (CEJ) measurements, lower coefficients of 0.71 and 0.59 were found for inter- and intraexaminer paired readings, respectively. Thus, measurements using the stent appear to be more reliable than subgingival CEJ readings.

Efficacy of a bioactive alloplast, in the treatment of human periodontal osseous defects-a clinical study

“…While measuring all the soft tissue parameters a fixed reference point at the apical edge of the custom made acrylic stent was used. Clark et al (13) have reported that the measurements using a stent appear to be better than the measurements made using cemento-enamel junction as the reference point. However, Trevor Watts (14) examined the possible sources of error with regard to probing measurement reliability with and without stent.…”

A comparative evaluation of bovine-derived xenograft (Bio-Oss Collagen) and type I collagen membrane (Bio-Gide) with bovine-derived xenograft (Bio-Oss Collagen) and fibrin fibronectin sealing system (TISSEEL) in the treatment of intrabony defects: A clinico-radiographic study

“…1990),[10] Relative Clinical Attachment Level (Clark et al ., 1987),[11] Radiographic evaluation by Long Cone Paralleling Technique.…”

Effects of Phase I Periodontal Therapy on the Quality of Life in COPD Patients

“…Each tooth was examined at four sites, namely mid-facial, mesio-facial, distofacial and at centre of lingual surfaces. In the present study an occlusal stent was used as a fixed reference point (Clark et al, 1987) 14 . After placing the stent over the teeth, the distance from the border of the stent to the base of the pocket was measured in mm using UNC -15, keeping the probe on vertical grooves prepared on the occlusal stent as a reference point to avoid clinical variations at different time points of measurement.…”