Relationships Between the Therapeutic Alliance and Reactions to Artistic Experience With Art Materials in an Art Therapy Simulation

Abstract

In art therapy, art-making plays an important role in the therapeutic relationship. To better understand the triangular relationship between the art therapist, the client and the artwork, this study investigated the association between the therapeutic alliance and reactions to artistic experiences with art materials in an art therapy simulation. The simulation consisted of a series of 6–8 sessions in which art therapy students were divided into teams composed of a permanent observer (art therapist) and creator (client). The client's role was to self-explore through art- making, and the art therapist's role was to accompany the client. Thirty-four students, all women, who played the art therapist role, and 37 students (one male) who played the client participated in the study. Of these participants, there were 24 pairs where both participants filled out all the questionnaires. A short version of the Working Alliance Inventory (WAI) was completed by the clients and the art therapists on the second session (T1) and on the penultimate session (T2). The clients also completed the Art-Based Intervention Questionnaire (ABI) at T2. Significant positive correlations were found between indices of the WAI for the art therapist and the client and the clients' reactions to the artistic experience with art materials on the ABI. The evaluation of the emotional bond between the art therapist and the client at the start of the simulation significantly predicted the client's reactions to the artistic experience with art materials at the end of the simulation and explained 45.4% of the variance for this variable. These findings highlight factors related to the development and influence of the therapeutic alliance, as well as the role of the artistic experience in art therapy and lay the groundwork for further research.

Role of Art Therapy in the Promotion of Mental Health: A Critical Review

“…Art has become a significant element of the therapeutic sector and is used in several recovery and treatment procedures [3]. Art therapy uses integrative techniques to captivate the soul, body and mind in ways that verbal expression alone doesn't appear to [1,4,5]. Art therapy is gaining popularity in mental health settings because it provides a recovery-oriented, person-centred approach that includes emotional, spiritual, social needs and clinical demands [6].…”

Artmaking in Elementary School Art Therapy: Associations with Pre-Treatment Behavioral Problems and Therapy Outcomes

“…A previous study reported a positive relationship between therapeutic alliance and response to artwork in a simulation in which 34 female students played the role of therapist, and 37 female students played the role of the clients. The findings showed that the stronger the therapeutic alliance, the more positive the client’s response to the creative experience and attitude towards the artistic product [ 81 ]. The relationship between therapeutic alliance and response to artmaking in art therapy has not yet been investigated in children, but for children the strengthening of the therapeutic alliance with the therapist throughout the year may become a motivating factor influencing the creative experience.…”

An in-depth introduction to arts-based spiritual healthcare: Creatively seeking and expressing purpose and meaning

“…Therefore, Art Therapy presupposes a "relationship, " whose dynamic is triangular: between the patient, the creation, and the therapist. The act of creation does not happen by itself, but through the establishment of a bond of trust provided by the therapeutic alliance, in a dialogic relationship (Gazit et al, 2021).…”