Relationships between Child Development at School Entry and Adolescent Health—A Participatory Systematic Review

Abstract

The relationship between child development and adolescent health, and how this may be modified by socio-economic conditions, is poorly understood. This limits cross-sector interventions to address adolescent health inequality. This review summarises evidence on the associations between child development at school starting age and subsequent health in adolescence and identifies factors affecting associations. We undertook a participatory systematic review, searching electronic databases (MEDLINE, PsycINFO, ASSIA and ERIC) for articles published between November 1990 and November 2020. Observational, intervention and review studies reporting a measure of child development and subsequent health outcomes, specifically weight and mental health, were included. Studies were individually and collectively assessed for quality using a comparative rating system of stronger, weaker, inconsistent or limited evidence. Associations between child development and adolescent health outcomes were assessed and reported by four domains of child development (socio-emotional, cognitive, language and communication, and physical development). A conceptual diagram, produced with stakeholders at the outset of the study, acted as a framework for narrative synthesis of factors that modify or mediate associations. Thirty-four studies were included. Analysis indicated stronger evidence of associations between measures of socio-emotional development and subsequent mental health and weight outcomes; in particular, positive associations between early externalising behaviours and later internalising and externalising, and negative associations between emotional wellbeing and later internalising and unhealthy weight. For all other domains of child development, although associations with subsequent health were positive, the evidence was either weaker, inconsistent or limited. There was limited evidence on factors that altered associations. Positive socio-emotional development at school starting age appears particularly important for subsequent mental health and weight in adolescence. More collaborative research across health and education is needed on other domains of development and on the mechanisms that link development and later health, and on how any relationship is modified by socio-economic context.

Exploring the Complexity of Telehealth Privacy Through a Lens of Adolescent Development

“…Blum et al (2012) emphasize contributors to adolescent development through a socioecological framework, including expectations and support at the individual level, interpersonal community assets, and macro-level factors such as policy. Each of these levels of the socioecological framework have been emphasized in recent literature as well, highlighting the importance of social determinants of health and systemic policy for healthy adolescent development (Achterberg et al, 2022; Black et al, 2021; Ferschmann et al, 2022; Hargreaves et al, 2022; Zanolie et al, 2022). Our study demonstrates that adolescent autonomy and independence may be driven by parental preparation and empowerment for adolescent ownership over their own health care.…”

‘Levelling up’ in the UK must involve a reduction in inequalities in children's life chances

“…Can children with social and emotional behavioural problems develop their cognitive abilities as well as those who don't? The answer to all of these questions is largely, no [ 10 ]. Without a central focus on improving child development, health and reducing child poverty as part of its policy programme, levelling up will be difficult to achieve, given the massive and growing regional inequalities in child wellbeing within the UK.…”