Relational legal consciousness and anticorruption: Lava Jato, social media interactions, and the co-production of law's detraction in Brazil (2017–2019)

Abstract

Starting in 2014, Brazilian politics was shaken up by the lava jato (LJ) operation, a law‐centered anticorruption initiative. LJ unveiled a large corruption scheme in Brazil's national oil company Petrobras, which involved Petrobras directors, political party officials, and large construction companies. LJ was both disruptive and contentious. To some, it started a new chapter in Brazilian history, marked by greater respect for the “rule of law” and a collective “state of mind” concerned with “ending impunity” and building integrity in politics and businesses. To others, it contributed to undermining democracy and the rule of law, paving the way for an autocratic leader—the current Brazilian president Jair Bolsonaro. This article sheds further light on those discussions by looking at LJ as a site of “legal consciousness” production. Empirically, the article focuses on conversations generated by lead LJ prosecutors on a major social media platform (Facebook) from 2017 to 2019. Considering this body of data, the article addresses the question: “When prosecutors and ‘the people’ talked about LJ, what did they talk about?” My findings support the more skeptical views of the operation. The exchanges between LJ prosecutors and their Facebook followers supported the co‐production of a cultural schema averse to the “rule of law.” These findings have implications for both legal consciousness and anticorruption research.

“Kill the chicken to scare the monkey”: Heavy penalties, excessive COVID‐19 control mechanisms, and legal consciousness in China

“…She criticizes legal consciousness scholars for abandoning the ambition to theorize about how law's hegemony is sustained, and even argues that perhaps the concept of legal consciousness should be abandoned. Legal consciousness scholarship, however, has continued to grow over the past two decades and has proven to be useful to other critical endeavors (de Sa e Silva, 2022). Chua and Engel (2019), for example, identify three schools of legal consciousness research: Identity, Hegemony, and Mobilization.…”

Relational legal consciousness in the punitive welfare state: How Dutch welfare officials shape clients' perceptions of law

“…I will explore this process through the analytical lens of relational and second‐order legal consciousness (Abrego, 2019; Chua & Engel, 2019; De Sa e Silva, 2022; Wang, 2019; Young, 2014; Young & Chimowitz, 2022). Rather than analyzing legal consciousness individualistically, a growing number of studies conceptualize legal consciousness as “a fully collaborative phenomenon” (Chua & Engel, 2019, p. 347).…”

“…Chua and Engel (2019, p. 348) suggest that “the “person‐by‐person” research methods used by legal consciousness scholars from the early 1960s to the present” might have to be replaced by new approaches that focus on the “observation and analysis of relationships and social interactions.” However, “what those methodologies might look like, and how they might be operationalized, is not yet apparent” (Chua & Engel, 2019, p. 348) This article wants to contribute to this discussion by introducing an innovative research methodology. While “[m]ost legal consciousness research—including relational research—is qualitative, using in‐depth interviews” (De Sa e Silva, 2022, p. 350), the present study uses quantitative research methods. This paper is based on an online survey among Dutch welfare clients and it is the first study that uses a correlation analysis to study the relational character of clients' legal consciousness.…”

COVID-19 and the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance Program in Puerto Rico: Anti-Corruption, Fraud Prevention, and Punishment

“…This definition equates corruption to bribery, and largely focuses on agent-based or individualistic acts of misappropriation (De Sa e Silva, 2020). According to De Sa e Silva (2022), corrupt individuals are seen as agents tasked with acting for the public good but who also engaged in rent seeking activities. This definition of corruption disregards the structural dynamic, historical process, and organizational instances that enable corruption (Wilson, 2023).…”