Circulation Journal Official Journal of the Japanese Circulation Society http://www. j-circ.or.jp the mean V E. 11 But Kato et al 10 took more strict criterion (at least 3 consecutive cycles and the amplitude >40% of the mean V E). The criteria of oscillatory breathing have not been widely accepted. There are some criteria according to authors' decision such as >15% 4 or >30% 6 or minimal average amplitude of ventilatory oscillation of 5 L/min. 3 Despite the clear association between exercise oscillatory breathing and outcomes in chronic heart failure, there are limited data regarding the mechanistic basis for oscillatory breathing. Ventilation is regulated through the feedback loop between pulmonary gas exchanging capillaries and chemoreceptors in the carotid bodies and the medulla. According to Dhakal et al, ventilatory instability and oscillations may arise from (1) increased circulatory delay, (2) increased chemosensitivity, (3) pulmonary congestion or (4) ergoreflex signaling. 12 In this issue of the Journal, Kato et al found that cardiac patients with more impaired cardiopulmonary dysfunction during exercise, as reflected in the CPX indices, have a longer CL of oscillating V E. 10 This finding supports the hypothesis by Murphy et al that oscillatory breathing is an important surrogate for hemodynamic impairment in patients with heart failure. 13 Heart failure patients with exercise oscillatory ventilation (HF + EOV) demonstrated a greater degree of hemodynamic impairment at rest, as evidenced by higher resting right atrial pressure, pulmonary arterial pressure, and pulmonary capillary wedge pressure and lower cardiac index (CI) compared with heart failure patients without exercise oscillatory ventilation (HF -EOV). Exercise filling pressures were also greater in the HF + EOV group than in the HF -EOV group, and HF + EOV patients had 25% lower cumulative exercise CI compared with HF -EOV patients (P<0.001). In multivariate analysis, exercise CI emerged as the leading predictor of EOV (odds ratio 1.39 for each 1.0 L · min -1 · m -2 decrement in CI, 95% confidence interval 1.14-1.70, P<0.001). 13 It is known that the oscillatory breathing noted at rest sometimes becomes unclear or even disappears during high-intensity exercise. This would also support the hypothesis that the circulation delay is an important factor determining oscillatory breathing, because the circulation time becomes shorter with the increased intensity of exercise as the result of the increase in cardiac output. 10 Exercise oscillatory breathing is a noninvasive, easily recognizable and reproducible submaximal exercise parameter observed during CPX. The prognostic significance of exercise oscillatory breathing and the apparent modifiability of oscillatory breathing with heart failure interventions make oscillaeriodic breathing, which is a form of irregular breathing characterized by cyclic variation of ventilation at rest and exercise, has been a recognized feature of heart failure for almost 2 centuries. 1 More recently, cyclic fluctuatio...