Regulatory reform as risk management: Why governments redesign micro company legal obligations

Abstract

This article contributes to the literature on small business and regulation by presenting and testing a comprehensive framework for explaining government motivations to implement regulatory reform targeting micro companies as beneficiaries. Following Haines, I adopt an alternative approach to the conventional market failure or equity rationales to explain government reform. Reform initiatives are conceptualised in terms of the management of three types of risk – actuarial, sociocultural and political. Combining a critical discourse analysis with an argumentative approach to policy analysis of documentary sources relevant to the Small Companies (Micro-Entities’ Accounts) Regulations 2013, I propose three contributions to the literature. First, reform policies are prompted by diverse risk concerns; they cannot be explained solely in terms of addressing market failure or equity considerations alone. Second, regulatory reform might, in certain circumstances, be better explained as a strategy for managing political and sociocultural risk rather than the actuarial risks that policymakers use explicitly to justify government action. Third, reforms might be motivated more by political and sociocultural risk where the legal change implemented is minimal, where robust research evidence to support the reform is limited or non-existent, or where the issue is of low salience to business owners themselves.

Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises (SMEs): The Engine of Economic Growth through Investments and Innovation

“…The research and innovation activities include, as a direct result, the increase of jobs, an economic increase and an increase in the quality of life. The new technologies support the new approach to social problems such as poverty, poor health and environmental degradation or work safety, since SMEs are supported by a series of national or regional regulations [75], specially designed as political and social risk management strategies.…”

Internationalization as a strategy for small and medium‐sized enterprises and the impact of regulatory environment: An emerging country perspective

“…Regulatory environment of business includes information on how the operation of the business is affected by rules and regulations (Dasanayaka et al, ; Urban & Kujinga, ). According to Kitching (), “… the legal framework is a fundamental and necessary contextual influence on small firm activity and performance, simultaneously imposing constraints and enabling various possibilities for action” (Kitching, , p. 296).…”

Perceived regulatory compliance in micro-firms: The case of English accommodation providers

“…Furthermore, micro-firms exist in most industries, and, for example, in the UK account for 95% of all firms, 32% of private sector employment, and 21% of private sector turnover (BEIS, 2021). They also encompass a variety of business types and are being targeted (at least in the UK) for specific regulatory reform (Kitching, 2019), and yet a thorough understanding of their unique compliance and the associated general management challenges are a significant limitation of the existing literature.…”