Regulations on palliative sedation: an international survey across eight European countries

Abstract

Background Palliative sedation is a commonly accepted medical practice. This study aims to clarify how palliative sedation is regulated in various countries and whether this may impact its practice. Methods An online survey requesting regulations on palliative sedation was conducted in Belgium, Germany, Hungary, Italy, The Netherlands, Spain, Romania and the UK. Purposive sampling strategy was used to identify clinicians from different medical fields and legal experts for each country. Regulations were analyzed using the principles of the European Association for Palliative Care Framework on palliative sedation. Country reports describing how palliative sedation is regulated were elaborated. Results One hundred and thirty-nine out of 223 (62%) participants identified 31 laws and other regulations affecting palliative sedation. In Spain, 12 regional laws recognize palliative sedation as a right of the patient at the end of life when there are refractory symptoms. In Italy, the law of informed consent and advance directives specifically recognizes the doctor can use deep sedation when there are refractory symptoms. There are also general medical laws that, while not explicitly referring to palliative sedation, regulate sedation-related principles: the obligation of doctors to honour advance directives, informed consent, the decision-making process and the obligation to document the whole process. In Germany, the Netherlands and the UK, palliative sedation is also regulated through professional guidelines that are binding as good practice with legal significance. Conclusions Palliative sedation is considered in the general law of medical practice, in laws regarding the patient’s autonomy, and through professional guidelines.

Should continuous deep sedation until death be legally regulated in Switzerland? An exploratory study with palliative care physicians

“…A recent international survey across eight European countries shows that ‘palliative sedation’ is commonly considered within the general medical law, in legal protections regarding patient autonomy and through clinical practice guidelines. 37 In some countries, specific recognition of the right to receive ‘palliative sedation’ is included in national laws. However, to the best of our knowledge, studies evaluating the impact of these specific legal regulations on clinical practice, especially on the reduction of the risk of excessive sedation, are lacking thus far.…”