Regulating a Revolution: From Regulatory Sandboxes to Smart Regulation

Abstract

Prior to the global financial crisis, financial innovation was viewed very positively, resulting in a laissez-faire, deregulatory approach to financial regulation. Since the crisis the regulatory pendulum has swung to the other extreme. Post-crisis regulation, plus rapid technological change, have spurred the development of financial technology (FinTech). FinTech firms and data-driven financial service providers profoundly challenge the current regulatory paradigm. Financial regulators increasingly seek to balance the traditional regulatory objectives of financial stability and consumer protection with promoting growth and innovation. The resulting regulatory innovations include RegTech, regulatory sandboxes, and special charters. This Article analyzes possible new regulatory approaches, ranging from doing nothing (which spans being permissive to highly restrictive, depending on context), cautious permissiveness (on a case-by-case basis, or through special charters), structured experimentalism (such as sandboxes or piloting), and development of specific new regulatory frameworks. Building on this framework, we argue for a new regulatory approach, which incorporates these rebalanced objectives, and which we term 'smart regulation.' Our new automated and proportionate regime builds on shared principles from a range of jurisdictions and supports innovation in financial markets. The fragmentation of market participants and the increased use of technology requires regulators to adopt a sequential reform process, starting with digitization, before building digitally-smart regulation. This Article provides a roadmap for this process. ABSTRACTPrior to the global financial crisis, financial innovation was viewed very positively, resulting in a laissez-faire, deregulatory approach to financial regulation. Since the crisis the regulatory pendulum has swung to the other extreme. Post-crisis regulation, plus rapid technological change, have spurred the development of financial technology (FinTech). FinTech firms and data-driven financial service providers profoundly challenge the current regulatory paradigm. Financial regulators increasingly seek to balance the traditional regulatory objectives of financial stability and consumer protection with promoting growth and innovation. The resulting regulatory innovations include RegTech, regulatory sandboxes, and

Concealed Risks of FinTech and Goal-Oriented Responsive Regulation: China’s Background and Global Perspective

“…Regulatory authorities could foster the development of the FinTech sector by implementing regulatory sandboxes or similar practice. 62 Zetzsche et al (2017). promotion can be driven by increasing market competition, or achieving greater levels of financial inclusion.…”

Disrupting Finance

“…Important technical guidance on security measures and SCA, incident reporting and complaints handling have been agreed and published. SCA is considered in more detail later below (see also Zetzsche et al 2017). 44…”

Bits and Bytes of Financial Regulation: The Regtech Environment

“…So indeed, Regtech has the potential to transform compliance across the financial services industry (The Irish Advantage, 2018). Despite the experiences of the Crisis, financial and technological innovation matters deeply, and regulators need to perform a balancing act between preserving stability, protecting consumers, and promoting innovation (Arner, Barberis, Buckley, and Zetzsche 2017). The Institute of International Finance (2016:3-4) list some of the technologies with potential to help on easing the compliance burden whilst increasing efficiency and effectiveness:…”

“…Increasing compliance costs and regulatory requirements made the use of innovative technologies a natural and promising solution not only for financial institutions but also regulators: as such we are now at the advent of the Regtech revolution (Arner, Barberis, and Buckley, 2017). Regtech is the management of regulatory demands within the financial industry through technology.…”