Refurbished or Remanufactured?—An Experimental Study on Consumer Choice Behavior

Abstract

Remanufacturing is one of the important means to achieve circular economy and improve the reuse of resources. But, compared with the reuse of old parts, most ordinary Chinese consumers are not familiar with remanufacturing. Because of this, the development of China’s remanufacturing industry is hindered. This paper introduces two kinds of consumer goods with different attributes, namely MP4 (the hedonic product) and cartridge (the functional product). The empirical study on the consumption behavior of Chinese consumers when they are faced with a variety of recycling options was performed. Empirical studies are divided into two stages: participants need to give hypothetical purchase decisions when facing situations of two products (new products and remanufactured products) and three products including refurbishment products, respectively. This paper analyzes the purchase intention and decision-making process of Chinese consumers for remanufactured products, new products, and refurbished products in these two situations. The consumers’ willingness to pay for remanufactured products and refurbished products is also part of the study. The experimental results verify that consumers have a different selection mechanism for new products, remanufactured products, and refurbished products, and there is also a certain relationship between this selection mechanism and the attributes of the product itself. The research shows that due to the different product attributes, consumers pay different attention to the environmental protection, quality, brand, price, and new and old preferences of products. The result of the model shows that the choice behavior of different products and their willingness to pay are also affected by different levels of these attentions. Through the research results, this paper finds conclusions like refurbished products have an impact on the development of remanufactured products, and consumers pay more attention to price but do not pay attention to environmental protection. The conclusion of the study provides references and practical implications for Chinese remanufacturing enterprises to formulate market strategy, for the government to formulate relevant policies, and for OEM production.

Contaminated by Its Prior Use: Strategies to Design and Market Refurbished Personal Care Products

“…These risks are then weighted against the perceived benefits of refurbished products. A lower price and environmental benefits can incentivize consumers to buy refurbished products [ 10 , 15 , 17 , 28 – 30 ]. A wide distribution of the refurbished product on the market, a good seller’s reputation [ 17 ], extended warranties [ 15 ], and marketing strategies, such as probabilistic selling [ 31 ], can decrease the perceived risks associated with refurbished smartphones.…”

Indonesians’ Perceptions of Auto Parts Remanufactured in China: Implications for Global Remanufacturing Operations

“…In this study, however, we hypothesized that the more consumers know about RAPs, the greater their awareness of RAPs' potential risks. This hypothesis is supported because typical consumers may not be familiar with remanufactured parts [67]. Therefore, their perceived risks or potential losses in purchasing RAPs are higher even when their perceived product knowledge is greater.…”

Tunneling the barriers of blockchain technology in remanufacturing for achieving sustainable development goals: A circular manufacturing perspective

“…This study considers 906 Chinese laptop owners in order to explore the relationship with the assistance of structural equation modeling. Chen, Wang, et al (2020) conducted an experimental study on customer intentions towards the remanufactured products with the Chinese context. Pisitsankkhakarn and Vassanadumrongdee (2020) studied Thailand's consumer perspective on remanufactured automotive parts to enhance the CE, in which a quantitative survey was used to collect data and structural equation modeling was used to analyze it.…”