We would like to thank KAUST for its support and the members of Seismic Wave Analysis Group (SWAG) for their helpful discussions. The Shaheen supercomputing Laboratory in KAUST provides the computational support. We thank Statoil ASA and the Volve license partners ExxonMobil E&P Norway AS and Bayerngas Norge AS, for the release of the Volve data. We would like to thank Dr Noalwenn Dubos-Sallee as the Associate Editor and two anonymous reviewers for their helpful suggestions