Reflecting on the Past: Children’s Services Workers’ Experiences of Residential Care in Scotland from 1960 to 1975

Abstract

While contemporary responses to the issue of historic child abuse in the Scottish context have tended to focus upon the experiences of former residents of institutional care, it is clear that much can also be learned from the narratives of former child-care workers. This article draws upon the findings of a recent project, the overall aim of which was to explore children's services' workers experiences of residential care in Scotland from 1960-75. Using an oral history methodology, in-depth, semi-structured interviews were conducted with twenty-three individuals who had experience of working in, or in connection with, residential child care services, followed by thematic analysis of the data. Results highlighted a range of both positive and negative experiences, and many of the issues still have a contemporary resonance. While we should guard against complaisance and be continually vigilant to safeguard and protect children, we should not allow a focus on risk-averse practice to obscure the merits of the more positive and nurturing elements of earlier residential childcare work.

Children’s quest for love and professional child protection work: the case of Norway.

“…My concern here is not to assess whether this is good or not, or in what ways and in what situations these warm personalised feelings may be legitimate. However, in this article I have argued that an unproblematised requirement that child protection workers must provide children with parent-like love may intersect with a current neo-liberal international tendency towards de-professionalisation, that may have problematic consequences for both providers and recipients of care in the child protection services (see Shaw and Kendrick, 2016).…”

Academic Disputes about Adult‐Child Sexual Contact: A Critical Realist Appraisal

“…Moreover, the arguments about a moral panic in relation to CSA have been reanimated recently by some academic social workers. This might reflect a need for re‐professionalisation after a period of demoralisation (Shaw and Kendrick, ). To be clear here, today most social workers interested in the protection of children would be wary about or hostile to the moral panic thesis.…”

Residential care and criminalisation: the impact of system abuse

“…It is also the case that placement outside the child's local area may limit and undermine the scope for work with the whole family, as well as curtailing social work contact and oversight. There have long been concerns about the abuse of children in care (Stein, 2006;Kendrick, 1998;Shaw and Kendrick, 2017) and such a lack of oversight might potentially leave the child vulnerable to abuse both within the placement itself and in the local community; indeed, the 2012 sex-trafficking convictions of a gang of men in Rochdale evidence the recently highlighted propensity of certain individuals and groups to target vulnerable young people for exploitation.…”